What is your favorite D&D setting?

[Crothian]

Uhm don't suppose we could get Scarred Lands in there? Please!!!

If not I'll go with Ravenloft.

its a d20 setting, not D&D........

 

[Nightfall]

Yeah but..uhm we got Trolls!

*is lamely defending his favorite setting uninclusion into this poll*

 

[Wes]

I voted for the Realms, but would have chosen Kalamar if it had been listed.

 

[Greyson]

Eberron Here

I voted for Eberron, which I think is a fantastic campaign setting. And, it has rekindled my fire for D&D.

Regrettably, Eberron is spelled wrong in the poll. Who wote the poll? The editors of Dungeon 113?

 

[Dr_Draco]

Well, I've always had a soft spot for the Realms, and has definitely been my favorite setting since I started D&D nearly 10 years ago.

Dark Sun is my number 2 setting, and I wish they get a real 3.5 update for it (3rd party or otherwise). Athas.org is great, and the stuff in Dragon and Dungeon was useful, but I want a DSCS hardback .

Rounding out my favorites are Planescape, Ravenloft, and Dragonlance. Greyhawk is a good one, too.

Haven't really tried out Eberron yet. I got the campaign setting and the Shadows of the Last War adventure. Just haven't had the chance to try a campaign there yet. From what I've read out the the ECS, I think I'm really gonna like it .

If we want to go non-WotC settings. The Scarred Lands is definitely my favorite non-WotC.

 

[Guillaume]

I voted for two choices on the list, but my real favorite settings are Kingdoms of Kalamar and of course my homebrew.

 

[Trickstergod]

its a d20 setting, not D&D........

Neither's Conan, Dawnforge or arguably even Kalamar, all of which have been mentioned.

Admittedly not in the poll itself.

Anyway, with that said, I do believe a vote for a homebrew isn't worth mentioning; obviously, most people with a homebrew will prefer it to a published setting.

The poll could do with some more options, though: An "Other (but not homebrew)" for those published campaign settings that fall through the cracks, as well as a "None" for those who like their homebrew and nothing else.

With that said, my vote? It's a toss up right now. Planescape and Eberron are both nifty, whereas Midnight is as well. I'd peg most fantasy d20 settings for 3rd edition as "D&D" settings. Official, though, that's another horse altogether.

 

[The Shaman]

D&D? Manifest.

d20 fantasy? Wilderlands of High Fantasy.

With respect to the poll? None of the above.

 

[Asmo]

Greyhawk here!

Asmo

 

[frankthedm]

First printing of darksun, before the Author's NPCs F'd the setting over.

Any material out there for pre Fall of Kalack or alternet setting were kalack's ziggarat is a setback, rather than lethal failure?