What is your favorite D&D setting?

[Coredump]

Kingdom of Kalamar... of course.

And it *is* a D&D setting, not D20. (or rather, not just D20)

 

[AdmundfortGeographer]

Regrettably, Eberron is spelled wrong in the poll. Who wrote the poll? The editors of Dungeon 113?

I noticed the same thing, and was just about to make a snarky post myself.

 

[scourger]

Out of that lot, I voted Greyhawk because it's the core setting. I've played a lot of Forgotten Realms and read many good books in those realms, but I've never DMed it so I can't call it my favorite. Birthright is intriguing even now, but I don't know enough about it. Similarly, I had much fun playing in Al'Quadim & Ravenloft but don't own them or know them very well.

 

[Buttercup]

Most of the settings in your poll are out of print. Of the ones currently in print my favorites would be Freeport and Kalamar. But best of all is homebrew, IMO.

 

[smilinggm]

This list is a great 2nd edition list of Campaigns. But as a 3.x list it is woefully incomplete.
That list does contain many Great Campaigns and if I only had to choose a campaign off of that list it would have to Be planescape. All of the other campaings are places that you can visit during the course of a long planescape campaing.

Now for my favorite 3.x Campaing it would deffinatly have to be Paradigm's Concepts "Arcanis: The world of Shattered Empires"

 

[Brennin Magalus]

Kingdom of Kalamar... of course.

And it *is* a D&D setting, not D20. (or rather, not just D20)

Only because of Kenzer's "shake down" of WOTC.

 

[Wombat]

Homebrew isn't a setting. Obviously the thread starter meant "published setting" anyway.

While I agree with your second statement (the poster meaning this to be "published settings", though this is never explicitly stated), I have to disagree with the first statement -- maybe "Homebrew" is not a specific setting (though now I am thinking it would be a great title for a silly campaign), it is indeed a setting.

Put me in the "Homebrew" camp as well.

 

[Acid_crash]

Where's Midnight? Conan? Scarred Lands? Mystara? Or any setting that specifically requires the use of the PHB that is D&D.

 

[Tuzenbach]

Blackmoor?

Valus?

PantsLand?

 

[Kanegrundar]

I'm all about my homebrew setting, IK, and Spellslinger, but sicne this is for D&D specific settings, I went with Planescape. There was just something about that setting that brought out the best in my creativity.

Kane