D&D (2024) What older setting do you want to see next?

[Digdude]

Just a note, I will shamelessly like any post that votes for Birthright. Make humans varied and important again!! With culture. Of all the places that need diversity and inclusion in this game, the human race in DnD is it!

 

[Ath'kethin]

Based on the handling of Spelljammer and Dragonlance, none of them. My interest in having a setting updated to a new edition/ruleset is inversely proportional to my interest in seeing everything distinctive about the setting - the bits that made me love it in the first place - removed or replaced.

 

[Haplo781]

Nentir Vale in a strong 2nd place makes my 4e fanboy heart smile.

 

[Lanefan]

Voted Mystara but would have also voted Birthright if allowed to. Third for me would be Nentir Vale or something similar - a points-of-light type of setting where most of the world is dark and full of terrors. After that, take yer pick.

 

[Haplo781]

Voted Mystara but would have also voted Birthright if allowed to. Third for me would be Nentir Vale or something similar - a points-of-light type of setting where most of the world is dark and full of terrors. After that, take yer pick.

I will probably do a "pick your top 3" poll with the top 5 choices from this one, as soon as it closes.

 

[James Gasik]

Argh. I so wanted to pick Birthright, but playing a dragon? The idea is so terminally cool!

 

[Mecheon]

Y'know, while I'm normally banging the Athas drum (Though with Kreen included in Spelljammer, my main desire from there is sorted), the more obscures like Birthright or the ones that give me stuff to muck about with like Mystara....

I'd really like to see Council of Wyrms again, y'know? Preferably in a day and age where "Only one person plays the dragon and falls to sleep for months on end so during that time the other folks run around" isn't a balancing feature. just, let everyone be dragon.

 

[Uni-the-Unicorn!]

Considering what they've done so far with RL and SJ, I'm not entirely sure I'd want them to tackle any other old setting.

YMMV, of course.

I would. I never really played the old settings and I am not really interested in the old lore. I would love a new take on some of these.

 

[Micah Sweet]

I would. I never really played the old settings and I am not really interested in the old lore. I would love a new take on some of these.

If you're not interested in the old lore, why would you care about the setting at all? You'd be just as happy with a new setting.

I don't think WotC should publish any of the old settings. They can't be trusted with them.

 

[Uni-the-Unicorn!]

If you're not interested in the old lore, why would you care about the setting at all? You'd be just as happy with a new setting.

I don't think WotC should publish any of the old settings. They can't be trusted with them.

I disagree. There is nothing sacred about old lore. It is still there If you want to use it. Let the new have some new.

I’ve been generally happy with the setting releases so far