This reminds me of something that happened in my first group. I was DM. The party cleric had managed to get himself blinded by a carnivorous ape, as a combination of a grapple, some bad luck, and a custom critical chart. I wasn't terribly concerned because I remembered he'd gotten an item not too long ago that could fix him up, though I didn't remember what it was. After combat they started searching their character sheets for a fix, and there it was, a scroll. Unfortunately he was the only one with the ability to use it, before he was injured that is. Even though he found someone who could cure him right after that adventure, he forever had " ... the blind" appended to his name, mainly because another party member hired a bard to write the story into song and spread it around.