TheSword
Legend
Best: Lords of Madness. So much gribbly wickedness in here. It has advice and crosses over into Eldritch horror as well as good old fashioned monster hunting... accept these monsters have culture and plans and they’re coming for you in the night. I particularly like the organizations fighting back like the Cerulean Sign - i always thought would make a great secret society.
Runner up: Curse of Strahd. Best campaign released for D&D since day 1
Worst: Magic of Incarnum. It just felt like a weird bloated addition at a point where 3.5 was already bloated enough. It didn’t resonate with other products. Instead trying to come up with something completely different. It felt more like a test balloon for 4e, and therefore pretty useless for 3.5e. One of the few products where I felt I got literally nothing positive from. Should never have bought it.
Runner up: Book of Nine Sword. Ridiculously broken in 3.5e. Similar issues to Incarnum.
Runner up: Curse of Strahd. Best campaign released for D&D since day 1
Worst: Magic of Incarnum. It just felt like a weird bloated addition at a point where 3.5 was already bloated enough. It didn’t resonate with other products. Instead trying to come up with something completely different. It felt more like a test balloon for 4e, and therefore pretty useless for 3.5e. One of the few products where I felt I got literally nothing positive from. Should never have bought it.
Runner up: Book of Nine Sword. Ridiculously broken in 3.5e. Similar issues to Incarnum.