The Game Preserve
305 Brown Street
West Lafayette, IN 47906
http://www.gamepreserve.com/articles.asp?ID=124
The Game Preserve is part of small chain of stores here in Indiana. Good selection of minis, traditional family boardgames, more modern boardgames (Euro and Ameritrash), cards, and a decent RPG selection. Has customer reward system.
Castle Comics and Cards
2133 S 4th St
Lafayette, IN 47905
Castle Comics and Cards is mostly a comic book/manga/ccg store (as you would guess from the title), has a bunch of other collectible stuff (action figures, fantasy swords, busts of Zena, etc..), hosts a bunch off CCG nights, and has a good RPG and boardgame selection
And the new kid on the block:
The Sage's Shoppe
307 Sagamore Parkway West
Wabash Commons Shopping Plaza
West Lafayette, Indiana 47906
http://www.thesagesshoppe.com/
Only been open for a couple months. Heavy on Flames of War, WarHammer, Click games. Small selection of D&D and CCGs.
All three stores here in town are run by nice people, and I have a hard time spreading my cash among the three of them.