• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

Would your group stop a woman from joining?

Would your group stop a woman from joining?


Ottergame said:
I've seen quite a large number of "girl gamer" posts (I guess this is the new fad, not my previous idea of "poorly translated foreign games" after all, darn), and that got me to wondering. My Ironclaw group would refuse to let a woman join our group, and I aggree with it for a very good reason. We were 5 gay men in a pretty...frisky game. A woman joining would have thrown that all out of whack.

I was wondering if anyone else out there played in a group that would have an issue with a woman joining.
Isn't it more about if the woman "clicks" with the gang than whether or not she is a woman. My group consists of three women and three guys. I'm more interested in finding a good player. It makes me wonder who else won't you let into your campaign? Do you segregate race as well. Will me, an African American, not be allowed into the game simply because of that?
 

log in or register to remove this ad


Well, maybe it's cuase we are all going through puberty, and can't stand the pressure.:uhoh:

Naw, the real thing for me is, there are none. I wouldn't care any different tho.
 

palleomortis said:
Well, maybe it's cuase we are all going through puberty, and can't stand the pressure.:uhoh:

Of course women would not understand

Naw, the real thing for me is, there are none. I wouldn't care any different tho.
Perhaps they are not attracted to your games or the type of games you play. I have had dm'd 5 girls in my campaign so far and know two or three girl gamers looking for campaigns. My last three girlfriends (that is someone of the opposite sex whom you spend time with) have been gamer chicks. The beginning of this thread is kind of sexist and offensive to minorities.
 


Cutter XXIII said:
"Guys-only" games are a fact of life. Mine is that way and won't ever change, despite possibly being perceived as exclusive or offensive. That's just too bad, from my POV, because we have invited women to join our group in the past. Not just for a single game, mind you, but as continuing members of the group.

The first of them was a great player. She really got into the character she'd created, came up with an appropriate background, read the rules often, role-played entertainingly, and generally added a hell of a lot to the group. I considered her a good friend, too, and the group would go out to play pool, drink some beers, what-have-you. Eventually I figured out that this woman had a thing for me, and was telling other players behind my back that I was making a huge mistake getting married to my fiancee. EXTREMELY awkward. When she moved away, there was great relief (on my part, especially).

The second of them joined the group for two sessions. She spent the entirety of both complaining about how she wasn't outside on such a nice day, if we were going to sit here we might as well drink wine, etc. etc. etc. She wasn't invited for a third game.

The third of them, and her husband, started as great players. But soon it became apparent that the two of them were just going to bicker all session long. When the wife threw a tantrum whose target was my minis, she was asked not to play again.

The fourth, a co-worker, was invited to join the group and seemed excited to do so. She went out and bought a rulebook immediately. In the two months she was a part of the group, she flat-out refused to do the baseline work that any player must do: read the rules & know your character. At the end, she'd never even bothered to complete her character sheet. In an awkward exchange, it was explained to her that we'd given her what we thought was plenty of time to ascend the learning curve, and she just wasn't doing anything at all. We even gave her another session after that, and still no change. So she was asked not to return.

That's my experience with females in our gaming group. Your experience, of course, is different. But I'm heartily sick and tired of reading on gaming boards that I'm a bad person, or offensive, for running a guys-only, "poker night" game.

I love my wife very much. She has no interest in gaming, but if she did I'd certainly work to nurture that. The rest of the women out there can find their own damn gaming group, because I've done my part.

Four times bitten, five shy.


I think anyone has a right to their opinion. And surely your opinion is based on bad experiences. But the majority of "no girl gamers posts" on here are simply because for some reason, as i interprit, some guys think there superior game wise than girls. I have had way more experiences with guys gaming as you have had with girls. I guess I read a post like this and all I think of is,"well what would happen if you had 4 bad experiences with 4 black people". I know racism and sexism still exist but it urks me to know that sometimes it is so blatant in society that people openly display it and pretend it is ok.
 


I assume that the poll is indicating that a woman would not be invited to the group, based on GENDER only? In that case, I cant possibly think of a reason why. If a specific woman with some personality conflict then I could see her being denied. But then, that wouldnt be "gender" based, it would apply to anyone. Nope, I cant see why I would ever prohibit a woman joining our group, just because of her gender. But, then again, I am a gender equalist. ;)
 

DonTadow said:
But the majority of "no girl gamers posts" on here are simply because for some reason, as i interprit, some guys think there superior game wise than girls.
Really? You either are reading an entirely different messageboard, or have no idea what you're talking about.
Space Coyote said:
I assume that the poll is indicating that a woman would not be invited to the group, based on GENDER only?
Nope. That's not said anywhere in the poll nor in the original post.
 

I can see where some of the wives our our gamers might think the scene had changed somewhat if there were women present, but that's a real stretch. I don't mind if anyone joins, sex, race and ethnic identity have zilch to do with whether or not we let you in. More like can you show up and bring some Coke...
 

Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top