Your favorite D&D setting?

This is easy.

My own. When you design your own setting and put enough work into it it can match your specific tastes perfectly.

Or at least as close to perfect as you can get a group of players to accept. :D


But that's probably not answering the right question.

In terms of published settings from what I've seen I like Kalamar the most.

I'm familiar with Kalamar, FR, Greyhawk, Mytra (or older versions of it), Ravenloft, Dragonstar, Dark Suns, Scarred Lands, Sovereign Stone, Lot5R, Wheel of Time (which isn't technicly DnD but close), Lankhmar, Thieves World, and City State of the Invincible Overlord.

So it's out of that limit of experience that I must choose.


I like Kalamar for it's consistancy and it's solid presentation of a world that is believable within the context of the genre it sets out to define.

Everything in Kalamar adds up to a larger whole and it all fits within that whole. There's nothing in Kalamar which fails to 'do things the Kalamar way'. And if you can accept the rules of a world like Kalamar you get enough detail at every turn to have that world make sense to itself. Everything the people do, every adventure hook, every physical feature, every angle of it... makes sense and gets some explaination.

You never once have to wonder why something is the way it is. Or how something is.

It's downfall is the writing style of the books. If your patient with it it holds a lot of riveting information. But that information does not leap out at you, you have to delve in for it.
 

log in or register to remove this ad



My signature says it all, World of Dramaer!

My own game world-setting, without a doubt. No other game world, in my opinion, is as detailed as my very own.

Watch for it Winter 2003 - Green Gryphon Games
 


1) Forgotten Realms 3e - Has a nice high adventure feel to it, and the book is about the best RPG supplement I've seen.

2) Old World of Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay - Grim and funny at the same time.

3) Middle-Earth
 

  1. Homebrew
  2. Middle-earth
  3. Planescape
    [/list=1]
    I do like to own other settings though: I have several Scarred Lands books, Rokugan books, WoT books, Star Wars books, etc., etc. It makes the job of doing #1 above that much easier.
 



1. Kingdoms of Kalamar (The most realistic and internally consistent setting I've ever seen.)

2. Birthright (when used strictly as a game-world setting, without the 'player-character nations' aspect--I'd love to see it re-released as a regular setting)

3. Mystara/Known World (Disjointed, yeah, but there was some pretty good stuff in there--and the 2e 'Karameikos: Kingdom of Adventure' box was terrific.)

Forgotten Realms, though vastly improved by 3e, is just too 'powered-up' for my liking; Scarred Lands just doesn't strike my fancy; and Greyhawk...Greyhawk is a very, very fond memory--but _only_ a memory.

Regards,
Darrell King
 

Remove ads

Top