Quigly is a bard and suppose to be able to influence people. The idea is not to look evil but to be a wide eyed innocent. You wouldn't trust No 3 has far as you could throw him but No 1, he's the sort of mark that the rest of the party would be looking for.Eh? That one doesn't look evil at all and I know someone that is using that pic and #2 already. How about some alternate choices:
However, as they are already in use and I now know the look I am aiming for, I'll have another look.