The Plane of Christmas: Where should it go?

[Protagonist]

ol' Saint Nick

Old Saint Nick
Old (Saint) Nick
Old Nick

 

[Shadeydm]

Adjacent to the demiplane of Candy.

 

[Lizard]

It just seems SOOOOO Feywild to me. If that fails, an Astral Dominion.

 

[doctorhook]

I'm quite impressed with the response so far! I'll be totally honest: When I started this thread, it was originally just an excuse to use the phrase "Elemental Christmas".

As I was writing the suggestions for the OP, the Feywild occurred to me, and it actually seemed like an excellent fit! Apparently, a fair number of ENWorlders agree.

There's no correct answer here; every choice puts a different "spin" on Christmas, and not necessarily an exclusive one, at that. (For example, the Plane of Christmas as a layer of the Abyss makes a lot more sense when one considers the chaos and evil involved with trying to find a parking space at the mall on the 23rd of December.)

 

[Umbran]

But what if he were?

As an aside, having an "evil" Santa Claus (like on Futurama, but more sinister and not at all comical) would be an interesting twist on ol' Saint Nick.

In certain cultures, they have, or have had such. For example, there is Krampus.

 

[thedungeondelver]

Some weird intersection of the para-elemental plane of ice and Elysium.

But that's this ol' "cosmic-wheel-for-me-screw-your-new-planar-system-and-get-off-my-lawn-you-young-punks" gamer's opinion.

 

[greatamericanfolkher]

It would be on the outer planes.
You kids and your “feywild”.

 

[Dragonbait]

In the feywild but its also in in concordant opposition to the realm of Halloween, which lies in the Shadowrealm and led by a surprisingly benign undead lord. Elemental gates in the shape of trees connect the two, along with gates leading to other American-celebrated holiday domains.

 

[Lizard]

In the feywild but its also in in concordant opposition to the realm of Halloween, which lies in the Shadowrealm and led by a surprisingly benign undead lord. Elemental gates in the shape of trees connect the two, along with gates leading to other American-celebrated holiday domains.

Thought of that too, huh?

 

[doctorhook]

In the feywild but its also in in concordant opposition to the realm of Halloween, which lies in the Shadowrealm and led by a surprisingly benign undead lord. Elemental gates in the shape of trees connect the two, along with gates leading to other American-celebrated holiday domains.

I like it! So where do we put the Plane of Easter?

...and Valentine's Day?