DUNE Movie: Thoughts, Opinions, and Impressions

Umbran

Mod Squad
Staff member
Supporter
She isn't mad at the start.

I didn't use the word "mad". I find that word to be less than helpful, as it usually refers to literary depictions of mental illness that aren't very similar to reality.

I said, "prone to mental illness". This is a woman who has been sexually abused by her brother, effectively kept in (admittedly pleasant) captivity, and sold into marriage. Her brother is brutally murdered before her eyes, iirc, and then she is taken on her wedding night in a way that hardly speaks "loving and informed consent".

If you want to think she's a well-balanced individual, who wields bloody violent power in a thoughtful, empathetic manner after all that, you are free to do so.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Jmarso

Adventurer
For me, LotR wasn't a great theater experience. Each film was too long to enjoy and take in during a single sitting. However, I preferred the Extended Editions, splitting each over several nights at home.
I like the extended cuts far more than the theater cuts, but sitting in a theater through those versions didn't cause me any heartache at all. Saw 'em each multiple times and planning the same for Dune.
 




Zaukrie

New Publisher
Topic drift happens.
So does people commenting on it. I'm not the first, and those posts seem to get likes.

I've been thinking a lot about my impressions of DUNE the last couple days, as more people I know see it and comment on it.

I'm 100% convinced had I not read the books, I'd like it more. It is a beautiful movie. The sound is amazing. The story they tell is good, and everyone I know understands what happened so far.

And yet, I hate how Jessica is portrayed, because I know she should be strong (and still "weak" in her love). And how Leto is just a prop. And a few other things......

So, I'll probably watch it again "soon" trying hard not to compare it to the books (which I'm usually good at, and actually WANT the movie to be different, because it isn't the same story or same genre......).
 

Jmarso

Adventurer
Somewhere in the dimensional cinematic netherworld that exists between 2021 and 1984, there is a perfect version of this movie that borrows certain elements and cast members from both.
 


J.Quondam

CR 1/8
Somewhere in the dimensional cinematic netherworld that exists between 2021 and 1984, there is a perfect version of this movie that borrows certain elements and cast members from both.
A few years after Villeneuve's sequel comes out, we'll get that director's cut. Maybe several director's cuts. And within a few years after that, just imagine all the fan-edits, deepfakes, and mashups that will be all over YouTube.
Perhaps from that utter creative chaos there will arise perfect version.
 


Remove ads

Top