D&D General What did you think of the Stranger Things D&D game?
- Thread starter Morrus
- Start date
Parmandur
Book-Friend, he/him
I've only seen the first two episodes. I really loved that scene: it made both D&D and Basketball look like great fun, and hey, both are great fun. Sucks that one character is being put in the middle like he is, but that's some real drama.
I didn't think it was necessarily a realistic depiction, anymore than the basketball game was, but it was a good cinematic presentation, and added a lot to the DM character.
Maxperson
Morkus from Orkus
I enjoyed it. The only thing about it that bugged me, and it was minor, was when the girl(can't remember her name) said she was a level 14 rogue. 1e had thieves. Other than that I loved the D&D scenes.
Tales and Chronicles
Jewel of the North, formerly know as vincegetorix
1) Vecna is not missing his whole left arm!
2) was there critical hit rules in the 80's ? I always thought it was more of a houserule thing that became a rule in somewhat recent editions.
3) Can an half-elf be a 14th level rogue? If we forget that there was no rogues back then.
and....it was so great. I immediately posted the Vecna Lives! from Dmsguild on our facebook group when I finished the episode.
2) was there critical hit rules in the 80's ? I always thought it was more of a houserule thing that became a rule in somewhat recent editions.
3) Can an half-elf be a 14th level rogue? If we forget that there was no rogues back then.
and....it was so great. I immediately posted the Vecna Lives! from Dmsguild on our facebook group when I finished the episode.
Maxperson
Morkus from Orkus
1e half-elves were unlimited in the thief class, so 14th level was okay.
So here's my issue...
A level 14 half-elf rogue gets a THAC0 equal to Elf, which is the same as a Fighter, Dwarf, or Halfling. So at level 14, her THAC0 was a -9-.
Which means a 19-20 is a hit because the best AC is -10, which pushes up the attack roll to a 19 or better.
Nog, Dustin's character, is a Dwarf and has THE EXACT SAME THAC0. (Unless he's either higher or lower level)
So why did the other gamers say "One in 20 chance" when it was, in fact, 1 in 10 or 2 in 20?!
A level 14 half-elf rogue gets a THAC0 equal to Elf, which is the same as a Fighter, Dwarf, or Halfling. So at level 14, her THAC0 was a -9-.
Which means a 19-20 is a hit because the best AC is -10, which pushes up the attack roll to a 19 or better.
Nog, Dustin's character, is a Dwarf and has THE EXACT SAME THAC0. (Unless he's either higher or lower level)
So why did the other gamers say "One in 20 chance" when it was, in fact, 1 in 10 or 2 in 20?!
UngeheuerLich
Legend
I liked it. I liked the whole season so far and I liked how things about dnd in the 80s were adressed.
TwiceBorn2
Adventurer
Because they aren't very good at math?
I haven't watched the series, just making a guess based on the excerpt you described.
jgsugden
Legend
There were a number of flubs from a mechanics perspective in that scene indicating the writers were modern players, not players with experience in the 1980s.
I'd love for someone to really get it right.
- Level 1 Dwarf?
- Rogue?
- Kukri?
- Vecna missing an arm?
- A rogue rolling percentile dice in AD&D - in combat? Maybe...
- But someone rolling a d4, a d8 and a d10 (percentile) all at once? And then a d4, d6 and d10 at the same time?
- How do the players know how many hps Venca has? Or that a powerful spellcaster in AD&D is going to be hurt, much less killed, by a weapon attack?
- Odds of success are 20 to 1 - and the PCs are rolling one attack roll each, with no need for a damage roll on the 'critical hit' (assuming they're using alternate rules for critical hits from Dragon or another source)? That makes no sense unless Dustin's attack was irrelevant.
- Most of the terrain and figures were time appropriate - but not quite all. And some of those dice did not look like 80s dice.
I'd love for someone to really get it right.
Last edited:
Benjamin Olson
Hero
Kudos to the show for knowing that even an intense, highly-demanding "killer" DM should be happy to see his villain defeated by a lucky crit right before the group can get wiped out, rather than getting upset that he lost or some nonsense. Most Hollywood depictions of the game would flub that point royally.
Similar Threads
