Chaosmancer
Legend
Exactly. It gives you a choice as the default.
Yep. In that isolated instance, yes. Now pick a fighter and try playing a special move other than the default moves it gives you. 5e is like that, too. The default for rolling characters is array or rolling. You get a choice by default.
Okay, so you CAN have a choice as the default. You agree with that being possible. Why then did you respond that I was wrong in this instance? To remind you of the conversation you butted in on.
The default can "choose one of these". That is still a default.
Not quite. A default is what you fall back to if you don't want to choose or can't be bothered to. If there's a "choice of defaults" that's not a default, as it still forces you to choose.
The default can be a choice. A default is not "what you do when you don't want to choose" it is "the standard or baseline"
And you focused on me saying, A default is not "what you do when you don't want to choose", which again, look up, was Lanefan's position. That a default CANNOT include a choice. If there is a choice, then there is no default because you must choose. And then, responding to "A default is not "what you do when you don't want to choose""
That's literally what a default is. A default is what happens unless you choose something else.
So, you were either agreeing with Lanefan that a defaul cannot include a choice, in which case you just backtracked and 180'd since you just said a default CAN be a choice... or you YET AGAIN jumped into a conversation to reply to me, without understand the context of the discussion. Because where you started trying to prove my position wrong, it turns out you support my position.
You have no such choice with the planes. The default is all of them unless you change the default.
Why is it impossible that we could rewrite the DMG to give a choice of the planes? Why is that not an option, because again in my journey to teach you about the conversation you are participating in, this idea of choosing a different cosmology STARTED with this conversation. Bolding so you can follow along:
If we are going to claim that all Cosmologies are equally valid and equally supported, then I'd like to see at least one other cosmology detailed and supported in the DMG. Right now, there is one cosmology that is treated as true, and a few names thrown out to make it seem like the others actually exist.
So, to translate for you. I was talking about rewriting the DMG, to change what it says, in comparison to what it currently does. So telling me that there is no choice with the planes means that you are either saying that while it is possible to have a default with choices, it is impossible to do so with the planes. Or, not understanding the conversation, you are once more trying to insist that I can't change things because the current books states... which completely ignores the fact I was talking about the NEXT book, which isn't this book.