Bagpuss
Legend
I thought our point here was to learn something about how the people playing these games feel, not win a rhetorical battle. So what is "the evidence"? The evidence is, for one, the women who tell us they don't want to play the game or feel uncomfortable because they dislike the art style with their overrepresentation of stereotypically beautiful, slim women who are on average a lot younger than the men, and who are more often dressed in revealing outfits drawn for the titillation of stereotypically male viewers than the other way around. And you can grab almost any TTRPG release, even today, flip through the art and see that these women have a point. So what I would say is: listen to the women and marginalized voices around you and what they have to say, and you will hear a wide range of opinions. That's much more important than us exchanging our own personal views on a forum.
Right so, by that reckoning (first part in bold) all of the art in Reasonably costumed women in fantasy art • r/ReasonableFantasy is still a serious problem, (please have a look though a couple of pages and see if anyone isn't young, slim and beautiful). The second part in bold we've shown that it isn't the case in TTRPGs for about two decades, although I will happily admit it is still an issue in fantasy art in a more general context.
If you flip through almost any TTRPG release from the last 15 years, I agree you will see slim and/or athletic young female characters, but not many if any drawn clearly for the titillation of male viewers. It is selling a fantasy, and generally that fantasy for most people is being young, athletic and healthy. Very few people want to play overweight, old, decrepit adventurers, so they won't be illustrated.
Judging by what you've chosen as an Avatar here you're not one to complain about slim, young character images.
You ever consider none of the men look like the people that play the game either, I've yet to see an image that looks remotely like me (except as perhaps a tavern keeper, or evil noble).
I think it will forever be a "serious problem" if you ever expect "fantasy" art not to represent people's fantasies of being young, healthy and beautiful.
That's not to say you can't have more representation, and that's pretty clearly happening if you look at the indie press TTRPGs where you often get overweight (yet still young and with flawless complexions) heroines illustrated, still not many overweight heroes oddly enough.
Last edited: