Picard Season 3


log in or register to remove this ad

You have and ejection system when you value crew lives and may be going into a hazardous situation. Which definitely applies to Starfleet.

The overwhelming majority of aircraft don't have weapon systems either.
Even aircraft with weapon systems very often don't have ejector seats. The only aircraft with ejector seats are fighters. Again, probably better to compare starships to naval vessels rather than fighter jets.

Then again, aircraft do come with seatbelts. Probably would have been a good idea on starships. :D
 

This latest episode felt like a lot of filler, with some great Data stuff and then the old gang finally all together in one room.
 

I might be in the minority here but I enjoyed the 1st season of Picard. It might be because I've been a huge fan of the Romulans since Balance of Terror.
I liked it too, and so I am assuming did quite a lot of people did too or they would likely not have made seasons 2 and 3. People who disliked season 1 (and/or 2) tend to be very loud about it, but don't mistake noise for majority.

Interesting, I never liked Section 31 (the whole concept is completely against what Star Trek is, IMO).
To me, that's what makes them such great villains! I was a bit concerned that the section 31 series would make them the heroes, but that does not seem to be happening at all now so that's a relief.

They already had Wesley last season. But with Changelings showing up, there's really only one big cameo that DS9 fans like myself will be looking for.
I consider myself a DS9 fan, and I am not sure who you are referring to. Sisko? Rom? EDIT: It's Morn, isn't it? Just make sure its not a speaking part, there are only two epsiodes left!

It's actually canonical, though still awkward. In Voyager they establish that the holodecks are on a separate power grid than the rest of the ship, and there's absolutely, positively no way that power can be transferred from them to anywhere else. Thus, regardless of how resource-starved Voyager gets in the Delta quadrant, they can still have holodeck episodes.
Voyager had it be a fact, but did not explain why. Picard stated that it was a deliberate design decision rather than a bizarre engineering oversight.

I vaguely recall that Changelings in DS9 started incorporating human blood, from.... sources, in order to get past the blood test thing. Someone who has watched more recently would likely know better.
That was suggested by Ben Sisko's father IIRC as a way they could get around the blood screenings. I do not believe it was ever explicitly confirmed that that was actually how they did it, but given some of the long-term infiltrations that were eventually revealed they must have had a way.

Geordie talks about how Data can't kill people. But, he had zero problems flat out murdering several people on the bridge when there was zero reason to do so. If you have control of the ship, you can simply use the transporters. Or drop a force field around them. Or increase the gravity locally and immobilize them. Or flood the area with gas. Or... or... or...
Geordie was wrong - we have known since TNG that Data can kill when the situation warrants it. And when a hostile group has taken over your ship and is threatening to murder the whole crew (and has demonstrated herself willing and able to carry out the threat on some crew members already), the situation warrants it!

Also, they did not have control of the whole ship, yet. And most of those things you mention as alternatives would not have worked against changelings at all, and those that might would have been less reliable than what they did do. Even if that had access to all those other systems, which is by no means a given.

No attempt to take out their engines. Nothing. Flat out killing every single person on the enemy ship when their shields were down and you had multiple options.
Leaving a heavily-armed ship like that lying around for whoever happens to come looking, even with the engines disabled, is just asking for trouble. Much safer for all concerned to blow the thing to hell.
 
Last edited:

Blowing them out the door and straight up murdering them, then blowing the ship afterwards? No attempt to take out their engines. Nothing. Flat out killing every single person on the enemy ship when their shields were down and you had multiple options.

Not very Federation.
LOL have you been watching Star Trek or not?

The Federation does that kind of stuff 24/7. They're not complete weeds. This isn't some well-developed alien civilization to be negotiated with. This is a bunch of absolute maniac fanatics who've been busily murdering and torturing and seem to intending to, at a minimum, Wolf 359 Starfleet.

People are often killed in Trek when they could, theoretically, be taken prisoner. It's usually a matter of whether it would be a risk to try and take them prisoner. Here, it clearly would be - they've been shown to be resourceful, surprising, and ultra-aggressive, and they're possibly telepath or otherwise capable of sending a signal. They have no facility which could definitely contain them. They can't be stunned - they can barely reliably be phasered on kill.

As for the ship, it's a missile boat which could blow the Titan to pieces if it started shooting, and "going for the engines" on a missile boat is very likely to have exactly the same effect as not doing that - it explodes. They're the ones who chose to fill their ship with about 5 vessels worth of missiles/torpedoes/bombs etc!
 

I consider myself a DS9 fan, and I am not sure who you are referring to. Sisko? Rom?
Sisko - i.e. Avery Brooks. If they managed to get him back on Trek after so many years away it'd be amazing (and no he's not a "drug addict" or insane before anyone suggests that - nothing indicates he's any more of a druggie than Stewart himself - you get one DUI...). On the other hand, he hasn't been on TV since the 1990s, and not in a movie other than The Captains since 2001. Cirroc Lofton said Brooks isn't retired and could be convinced, back in 2020, though, so maybe. Talking of Lofton, failing Avery Brooks, he wouldn't be a bad choice. Also christ I didn't realize at the time, but Lofton is the same age as me. Or Nana Visitor actually, Kira was involved with the Changelings too (particularly via Odo but not solely).

My suspicion is we don't get any of the above but we shall see!
 

To me, that's what makes them such great villains! I was a bit concerned that the section 31 series would make them the heroes, but that does not seem to be happening at all now so that's a relief.

Problem is, most of the writers still try to convey that the idea of section 31 necessary - even if some of the individuals are villains. The very concept irritates me.

And the show, while delayed is still inching forward.
 

LOL have you been watching Star Trek or not?

The Federation does that kind of stuff 24/7. They're not complete weeds. This isn't some well-developed alien civilization to be negotiated with. This is a bunch of absolute maniac fanatics who've been busily murdering and torturing and seem to intending to, at a minimum, Wolf 359 Starfleet.

People are often killed in Trek when they could, theoretically, be taken prisoner. It's usually a matter of whether it would be a risk to try and take them prisoner. Here, it clearly would be - they've been shown to be resourceful, surprising, and ultra-aggressive, and they're possibly telepath or otherwise capable of sending a signal. They have no facility which could definitely contain them. They can't be stunned - they can barely reliably be phasered on kill.
Indeed - they had Vadic imprisoned the previous episode, and it didn't work out well for them. She's too resourceful to be reliably contained.
As for the ship, it's a missile boat which could blow the Titan to pieces if it started shooting, and "going for the engines" on a missile boat is very likely to have exactly the same effect as not doing that - it explodes. They're the ones who chose to fill their ship with about 5 vessels worth of missiles/torpedoes/bombs etc!
Plus, even if they could reliably take it intact, they couldn't possibly hold it. They were down to a skeleton crew aboard the Titan even before Vadic and her goons slaughtered half of them, and they're fugitives from an already-compromised Starfleet. They can't put a prize crew aboard the Shrike - they barely have enough people aboard the Titan to run it, probably too few at this point if it wasn't networked with Datalore.
 

Sisko - i.e. Avery Brooks. If they managed to get him back on Trek after so many years away it'd be amazing (and no he's not a "drug addict" or insane before anyone suggests that - nothing indicates he's any more of a druggie than Stewart himself - you get one DUI...). On the other hand, he hasn't been on TV since the 1990s, and not in a movie other than The Captains since 2001. Cirroc Lofton said Brooks isn't retired and could be convinced, back in 2020, though, so maybe. Talking of Lofton, failing Avery Brooks, he wouldn't be a bad choice. Also christ I didn't realize at the time, but Lofton is the same age as me. Or Nana Visitor actually, Kira was involved with the Changelings too (particularly via Odo but not solely).

My suspicion is we don't get any of the above but we shall see!

They got Nana Visitor for Lower Decks already - so she's likely available (though "in person" may be a different get than for animated).
 

They got Nana Visitor for Lower Decks already - so she's likely available (though "in person" may be a different get than for animated).
Somehow, there has got to be a way to get these two women on the same show, at the same time. Tybee's own mother thought she was on the show, when they were watching a DS9 rerun.
Image1.jpg
 

Remove ads

Top