For me personally? I don't have a particular preference for it.
At the same time, I acknowledge that other people play the game, and they may have fantasies that differ from my own. Some of those people likely have backgrounds, points of view, and life experiences that likewise differ from my own. That makes them no less valid.
I do not believe that I should wholly dismiss the desires of others due to gender identity, as I (personally) feel that doing such would be closed-minded, potentially bigoted, and against the general ethics by which I choose to live.
Not wanting cheesecake--or let's face it, it's sort-core erotica--in an RPG book that isn't about that sort of thing isn't dismissing peoples' desires due to their gender identity (
or their sexuality).
I should also hope that most people, regardless of their gender or sexuality, are capable of reading books that don't have cheesecake in them. If they can't, if their ability to enjoy an RPG book is literally diminished because there aren't acres of skin on display, well, that strikes me as a
them problem.
Can I understand why a chainmail bikini might rub someone the wrong way? Yes - both figuratively and literally.
Can I understand why someone wouldn't be bothered by it? Also yes, and it's no less out of place than the weird belt fetish that 3rd Edition sorcerers seemed to have.
But now imagine that
that was the sort of thing nearly every male character was drawn like, no matter what. For decades. Terrible weather? Middle of battle where they're in the front line? In the of a royal court, where everyone else is dressed in formal clothes? Nope, it's pin up-palooza, all day long. And then, when it became more common for male characters in outfits that are actually dressed appropriately for the circumstances, other people complained about it and called the art "sanitized."
Should it be gotten rid of entirely? Nah. But c'mon. There's a time and a place for everything, and most of the time, that sort of art is just
gratuitous.
In the end, it's a bit of a wash for me. However people beyond myself play the game and have different points of view.
If, for a moment, I can ignore all of that; my own personal preference would be for ttrpg artwork that is less clean. By "clean," I mean that in a literal sense (not as any sort of commentary on scantily clad bodies). A little bit of artwork that shows adventurers with a bit of dirt and grime or perhaps dinged armor and the signs of a hard journey would be nice, rather than picture-perfect AI-Instagram-model figures.
This I agree with completely. A few scars as well. One of D&D characters has a fencing scar on her face and a missing horn.
On the topic of the thread: I'm okay with (and supportive of) adventuring folk who aren't perfect and don't look like airbrushed movie stars. At the same time, art should fit the story being told and make sense in the context for which it is given.
A warrior with crooked teeth and a nose that's obviously been broken a few times? Sure; cool
A wizard with soot on his robes, Coke-bottle glasses, and vitiligo? Sure; cool
A charismatic nymph being drawn like a frumpy hobo with a methamphetamine dental plan?
That doesn't work for me.
Nymph, probably not. It would be inappropriate for the monster type.
But, well... this is a piece of old D&D art:
This next art is from Thirsty Sword Lesbians. Ignore the art style and imagine it was painted like the picture above.
The D&D art may be more "medieval," but it's otherwise basically the same thing: a female spellcaster in not very much clothing at all. I kind of wonder how many people would be cool with cheesecake that looks like the TSW art (and weren't cool with it just because they have type and/or fetish), and how many would suddenly start wanting women to be more fully dressed if
this was the type of women that was being drawn.
And for the record, TSW has a
great variety of physical female bodies, ranging in body sizes and how much they're clothed. It's the kind of variety
I'd like to see, for characters of all genders, in D&D books. I was, for example, quite pleased to see the following bit of art in the Level Up
Adventurer's Guide, as the illustration for the cleric entry: