D&D (2024) Reworking the 2024 Hiding rules

[TaranTheWanderer]

This implies that being aware can make you worse at searching for someone than when not being aware because you always can roll subaverage.

Nah, it just means that you can actively use your action every round as opposed to just getting the initial check. I always default to the passive check as a minimum but that’s just me. Unless they’re doing opposed rolls.

 

[Retros_x]

I mean problem in the sense that this issue seems to take up a lot of real state on the boards.
When I’m DMing I just look at the map and make decisions. I’m never going to messer square corners and diagonals etc and debate game theory.

But then facing not being a part of the rules makes it even easier to make decisions as a DM? One less thing to worry about.

 

[Retros_x]

I always default to the passive check as a minimum but that’s just me

I hope you don't have rogues in your party. Because they get a feat on 11th level to let them basically do this. Its clear that the rules don't intent passive check as general skill floors.

 

[TaranTheWanderer]

I hope you don't have rogues in your party. Because they get a feat on 11th level to let them basically do this. Its clear that the rules don't intent passive check as general skill floors.

I’m not sure how clear it is. Lots of DMs do this just to avoid the very issue you brought up.

 

[KYRON45]

But then facing not being a part of the rules makes it even easier to make decisions as a DM? One less thing to worry about.

Does it? No one can agree how stealth and hiding works.

 

[renbot]

This is what I plan to implement in my game. It is more generous than the 5.5 rules but I want characters to be able to use their stealth if they have invested in it.

HIDING RULES

When you are hidden you cannot be detected by sight or hearing, although creatures with other senses might be able to detect you. You cannot be targeted directly by spells or other effects but the space that occupy can be targeted via area of effect spells or sheer luck.

You can attempt to become hidden by making a Stealth check as long as you are obscured or have cover. The Stealth check is made with disadvantage if you are only lightly obscured or have less than 3/4 cover. The check is compared to another creature's Perception check or Passive Perception score depending on if the creature is actively searching for you. You remain hidden until immediately after you meet one of the conditions that negate the hidden condition or require another Stealth check.

Conditions that automatically negate the Hidden condition:
1. Attacking
2. Casting a spell with a Verbal component.
3. Making any noise louder than a whisper
4. Ending your turn in an area with no cover nor obscurement
5. The DM decides you no longer meet the conditions to remain hidden.

Conditions that require another Stealth check:
1. Moving more than half your speed
2. Moving through an area with no obscurement or cover.
3. Ending your turn in an area that is lightly obscured or where you have less than 3/4 cover (made with disadvantage as per above).