Recent content by Scribe

Another update, truly we are blessed. Lots of stuff I would have missed on Kickstarter too.

I can think of maybe one other thing, but it will depend on what Western Reaches expands on fully.

She mentioned there will be Bastion like rules, and I believe something else. After this, I am really going to be challenged as to what else I could really need for SD at all beyond a huge dungeon.

They are engaging the game, "nothing in the rules impacts me, thats not how Warlocks work so we are good to go" is quite literally a failing of the game, which the player is knowledgeable enough to engage. Now, the spirit of the game? Sure, you got me there. The spirit of the game however has...

Ah yes, we had the 'well your preferences are just bad gameplay' and now 'well my players are simply good and yours are by comparison obviously not'.

I'm not sure he's wrong, or if he is today, based on that rate of advancement, I dont think he will be for long.

My comment from the other thread. Like the classes, like the spells, Dismember is pretty grim lol, and looking over the Library, looks really cool. The tone is dark, and I'm really wondering how much the Chittering is going to get people, but it is a high level zone. The Shadowdark doesnt mess...

-- And your gone.

Ah yes, arguing for hearts and minds, very productive in a thread asking for exactly what your pushing again. Essentially, thread crapping? Impressive.

Did we? Weird and erroneous analogies, straw man arguments? Nah.

A - Sure thing, as is your desire to have it not be a thing. B - This is a D&D General thing, so you are incorrect. C - This remains a nonsensical statement. D - Your opinion only. Enjoy your game, there is zero value in discussing this.

A Cleric, channeling the power of a D&D God, can raise the dead, among many other miracles in "real world" terms. How often is the Pope seen raising the dead, or calling down pillars of fire?

Holy christ dude. God's in D&D? Real. God's in D&D? Cosmic, Plane shaping, power. God's in reality? Maybe not real. God's in reality? Maybe no power. I have no clue why you keep trying to appeal to the real world here, it's nonsensical.

Man, you can have a preference, but these still are God's right? This analogy is painful to read. The God/Patron empowers? The God/Patron revokes. Simple.

As for CS 5. Like the classes, like the spells, Dismember is pretty grim lol, and looking over the Library, looks really cool. The tone is dark, and I'm really wondering how much the Chittering is going to get people, but it is a high level zone. The Shadowdark doesnt mess around. I think CS...