Search results

Well to me tome of battle is the best 3e book so I'm type 2 to the end, I really like "wuxia" like fighters and all. Like a "tough" shoud be tough, high DR, no forced moved, etc A "power"fighter should be powerfull, high damage, break walls with a strike and etc And a "quick"fighter should...

I think that this "hardcover-dead tree books" thing is the problem here :-D

WoTC don't be Blizzard, be linux, Release early, release often

A "combat pool" that can be used for increase attack, damage, saves or AC would be a good fighter ability in a system like this.

I see only pros, one thing that I never liked is that is hard to hit with no-optimal attacks in d&d, without level scalling improvisational attacks are easier. And we cna now have monster with low AC high damage, high AC and low hit, this kind og thing.

I would make it simpler, jump OR acrobatics vs reflexes, level apropriated damage and knocks the target... The problem with d&d (3e and 4e) is that it is very hard to hit with the wrong abillity, and there is too many bonus that are need to the math works... in a simple game like savage worlds...

I like it, a iron golen should have a easy to dodge but very damaging if hit attack

Let me tell: the stats for house cats in 3e are ridiculous, look at that: Cat :: d20srd.org as each attack causes at least 1 point of damage a house cat will kill a commoner 1 most of the time! House cats DON'T need stats!

If the game was other than d&d it would be true, but d&d spell are full of useless fluff the be used as generic powers. In savage words or muttants and masterminds it is true, but d&d? Like the big area damage effect is a fireball, so if I want a cold monster with a big area damage effec? You...

Really bad if true, nothing here is interesting to me.

This to me is good, IF the game needs the + weapons it is best if they are simply good weapons and not magic weapons...

More damage and a bonus to hit should be some of the powers of a magic weapon, but the common + wepons shouldn't be the default magic weapons, there is no mechanical problem with a flma sword without the + bonus.

I think that the problem here is that a certain ability is too important, if there is a real a choice between more offence (STR) or defence (dex) it works. If d&d should be a more skill based game it should have a better skill system, it shouldn't be diference between stealth and fighting...

Why? I much prefer if stat bumps are the only way to increase attacks/saves, it makes the game simpler if you attack isn't "str bonus+class bonus+level bonus+feat bonus".

Well at least everybody hates kenders, it is something :-D

Well to me HP should be CON score + a class bonus per level, like 4e but with lower numbers. So a 14 con fighter should have like 18 hps and a 10 level one 54, so it is more like 3x.

I really don´t like the "classic" races (elfs, dwafs, halflings and gnomes) if they are used in the classic way, but with some modifications (they all can be cool, like in darksun, darksun halflings rulez.

I love the hexblade(4e) and swordmage, the thing is I prefer if it isn´t a fighter with wizard spells or a wizards that uses a sword, it need to have unique powers.

It is a cool option, and not only for high level characters, but should be optional. I have no interest in playing as a king or something like this, and this shouldn't have be the fighters "power".

I find RPG is a very cheap hobby, even if I don't like 5e much I can don't buy a 60 dolar videogame to buy the basic books..