Search results

  1. BigRedRod

    Bolts, Open Lock and Thief Tools

    My problem with just applying open lock to the situation is that the skill description states quite clearly that it is a mastery of just openingvarious kinds of lock. Sawing through a bolt seems a little detached. I'm not trying to make my players make noisy entrances through bolted doors. I...
  2. BigRedRod

    Cleric gets feat he can't use: Am I reading correctly?

    The domain grants it despite the Cleric's lack of prereqs. There isn't an issue here, the Cleric gains Weapon Focus and the associated bonus I can see how this could appear confusing though as I'm not sure it is explicitly stated
  3. BigRedRod

    Bolts, Open Lock and Thief Tools

    Several times during the course of my DMing I've included doors which were bolted from the inside, and in each case my players have usually fallen in to a well of despair at the sight of them and set about forcing their way through the portal. I use interior bolts on doors where it makes...
  4. BigRedRod

    A waste of statistics and an illustrators time.

    Meenlocks. I can concieve of no use of them that wouldn't involve the players sighing
  5. BigRedRod

    Morality in your D&D - b&w or gray?

    D&D is designed to be black&white, which is a shame as it is difficult and/or boring to play a game with no middle grounds
  6. BigRedRod

    The Killer Joke

    This joke just doesn't work as well converted in to a D&D setting
  7. BigRedRod

    Weaving the plot around the characters

    Well I'll just talk about one of my games. The newest one as I'm quite sure that none of my players from there read this forum The premise of the game is that after you die your soul lives on. Spirits linger until the Red Moon comes, the Red Moon appears when the Netherworld opens to the dead...
  8. BigRedRod

    Weaving the plot around the characters

    It seems to me that the best type of gaming is that which revolves around the players, and yet it seems the rarest. Published modules don't take this in to account for the most part (usually just giving a little "perhaps a player recieves a message from his uncle about blah blah" in one of the...
  9. BigRedRod

    Are LA races ever worth it?

    The 3.0 approach to level adjustment was far superior to the feeble attempts set out by SS Quite simply +1 HD doesn't equal +1level The monsterous progressions really screw things up too With a good DM, you can play non-standard races without sacrificing power
  10. BigRedRod

    What do you do to simplify or speed up your D&D/d20 game?

    We always dump encumberance. I assume everybody does this and the rules are provided solely for video game translations. If it ever becomes an issue we just use common sense coupled with superhuman abilities. Not given any problems to us or anybody yet
  11. BigRedRod

    Creature Types/Subtypes & Classification

    I don't try and force everything, or even most things. But D&D attempts to be elemental when it clearly isn't suited just for the sake of completeness Return to the Temple of Elemental Evil is a good example of where it tries and falls apart. Earth doesn't have an energy type and so it's...
  12. BigRedRod

    Creature Types/Subtypes & Classification

    You seem to have misunderstood, D&D is inherently Elemental in it's makeup and yet it manages to deal with the elements themselves in such a half-arsed way The standard D&D cosmology sets up a simple system of elements Fire, Water, Air, and Earth The monsters and spells however do not fit this...
  13. BigRedRod

    Creature Types/Subtypes & Classification

    Types Abberration Animal Construct Dragon Elemental Fey Giant Humanoid Magical Beast Monstrous Humanoid Ooze Outsider Plant Undead Vermin Sub-types Air Aquatic Cold Earth Fire Water Goblinoid Incorporeal Lawful Chaotic Evil Good Native Reptillian Shapechanger Just a quick glance reveals that...
  14. BigRedRod

    Creature Types/Subtypes & Classification

    Much like the piss poor element system in D&D I'd scrap all of the type/subtype system for creatures and just go back to the drawing board Too many of the types seem completely arbitary and secondary to any kind of rule mechanic
  15. BigRedRod

    Anyone know about NETHACK, like how to win it?

    Play ADOM(http://www.adom.de/), its like what nethack would be like if it was twice as good ;) I cannot wait for the "sequel" Jade, although I just tend to love most roguelikes
  16. BigRedRod

    Gridless Combat

    There is no real issue doing like the GW games 1 square = 5ft = 1 inch Bang Problem solved
  17. BigRedRod

    Springing surprise tricks in the game.

    Dimension door only works on willing targets though...
  18. BigRedRod

    Are Psionic's now Core Rules?

    Nope They won't be until they include the rules in one of the three core books either
  19. BigRedRod

    Lycanthropes - As tough as it gets (a rant against 3.5 DR).

    I really hated the 3e DR rules. I don't care how magic your sword is, you need silver to do proper damage to a werewolf 3.5 is a much better idea, still not perfect though. Although I can understand why they didn't want to make certain monsters immune to all damage per special materials
  20. BigRedRod

    Original Campaigns from Wizards Campaign Creation contest

    As impressed as I was by Eberron I'd love to read some of the other high ranking settings. A complete list would seem a bad idea, we get enough crappy settings flooding the internet, I'd prefer just to see the cream
Top