Search results

I used to see these types of arguments come up when it came to combat and meta-gaming. Questions like: Should players know Monster AC? Hit-Points? Or the absolutely iconic, Do you know a troll has regeneration? People who argued that players shouldn't know this would often cite "realism" or...

Definitely a "No" for me. I moved to Pathfinder and I'm pretty happy with that, nor am I the biggest fan of the playtest material. That being said as a fan of all things D&D and D&D adjacent, I'll probably acquire them eventually. But in 2024? Not likely. Maybe a year or two after that, when...

I don't think the act of tracking resources is fun, but it can create fun gameplay. Example, Darkest Dungeon. Not a table-top RPG sure, but that entire game is centered around "Resource Management" and is basically an homage to Old-school D&D. Those resources include equipment like Torches &...

I don't hate it. Some things seem better, some things seem worse.In general, its kind of hard to be excited for "more of the same." I'm somewhere between 'Low' and 'Meh.' Voted low because the Druid playtest is a mess.

I need to wait for more information. The OG three Jerry Holkins, Mike Krahulik and Scott Kurtz made AI for me and it seems like Scott and Mike aren't really invested in it anymore. The crossovers with the C-Team mand Dice, Camera Action just don't interest me. Of course I liked Rothfuss too but...

Can't go wrong with Dragonslayer

Granted I'm not one of his patrons, but I absolutely would love to see him create something new.

Definitely not, and I think his prediction is born out of fear and frustration and not accurate. When the OGL leaks first started dropping, I was wracked with anxiety for days. I thought every company like Kobold Press and Paizo would fold overnight. . . Pathfinder 2e would be cancelled, just...

I'm a younger player, started with 4e in High School around 2012, really got into it in College when 5e dropped in 2014. For most of my gaming life I was playing or running the more "narrative" style of games because that was the norm. That was, as I understood, the intended way to play. In the...

This was a huge shame too as AiME sucked. It was literally just 5e with the magic ripped out. Classes were nearly identical to 5e but with different names and no magic, so martial classes were easily twice as good as those based on spellcasters like the Warden or Scholar.

I like Vancian magic as a gameplay mechanic. Its interesting to me personally and people often say restrictions breed creativity. So, yes, I suppose it is limited, but that's by design and I like it that way. Plus, this is a game after all. There is a point to be made that magic in the...

I mean I would love to hear about it. I'm 26 I play 5e and Pathfinder 2e of course but I'm really into the OSR scene and the different philosophies of play back then. I'm read blogs and seen videos about older players experiences but that content is few and far between. Personally I find...

No, because it would imply that the DM is giving them items and experience disproportionate to the challenge. IME, most DMs aren't doing that. However, its still very easy for PCs to punch above their weight. Its been discussed ad nauseum how the CR system doesn't work well and I think that's...

I said lore - which I stand by - but I definitely try to include the majority of player options within my lore. At the very least I try to include everything in the Player's Handbook as a baseline. But I also don't sweat 1 or 2 things not making it in. There's so many options my players are...

I think it will create more of a "theoretical divide" than a divide at the table. Basically, there will be a divide, but it will mostly be players arguing on reddit and forums like this one about the superiority of one versus the other, whereas when you get to the table most players will just...

Characters from both might be equally powered, but I don't believe you'll be able to mix features from both books together without work. IMO, that's not backwards compatible. "Backwards adaptable?" Maybe. We'll have to see what future playtest releases hold.

"Backwards Compatible" to me implies that both games can be used together with no (or minimal) issues or adaptations. Already I feel that One D&D does not fit that mark, as the way you generate stats and racial features means that 5e and One D&D characters at this moment are fundamentally different.

We occasionally used things like Discord & Google Sheets to track items, equipment and treasure. But we never did this in-character. So I said False. It was all OOC book-keeping. We've stopped using it, now that we use Foundry VTT, as we track all of our items and treasure through journals in...

It certainly mimics the style of adventure Matt Mercer runs for Critical Role. I remember somebody made an animation of the party's travels for the second campaign and it's kind of insane how much of the map they cover. If you padded this out a little (some side quests and random encounters...

Watch dogs are a real thing, and a common trope in a lot of genres, not just fantasy, so yes I would allow the use of the animal to confer some kind of bonus, but with some caveats: The Character and the Animal are not the same being. Having two creatures means the likelihood of spotting an...