2006 WotC D&D Product Survivor - Round 14 (Final Five)

[Glyfair]

Last rounds voting off of Expedition to Castle Ravenloft brings us to the final five. The product getting the most votes will be removed from the list.

It was a close vote between EtCR and Complete Mage with Red Hand of Doom being not too far behind. Will the anti-adventure crowd swing the votes against RHoD? Will weekend voters be the ones who remember that there was a 30+ page complaint thread about the Fiendish Codex decisions? Will the anti-PHB II crowd get a boost from Psion's rallying cries? Which will go next round?

 

[Vanuslux]

I voted Red Hand of Doom based on the fact that it's an adventure, not a sourcebook. I love good adventures, but I'm far more fond of good sourcebooks.

 

[Nikosandros]

Once again, I turn my guns against Complete Mage...

 

[delericho]

I'm going with Complete Mage. It's the only book on the list I don't own, because I'm not interested in the subject matter at this time. (I'll get the second batch of Completes only when all four are released.)

Also, I know that all of the other four are excellent books.

 

[Psion]

Repesentin' against class glut. My vote goes to PHB II.

 

[Steel_Wind]

Reserve feats? Get thee gone! Die Complete Mage - DIE.

 

[crazy_cat]

I voted Red Hand of Doom based on the fact that it's an adventure, not a sourcebook. I love good adventures, but I'm far more fond of good sourcebooks.

Same here.

 

[WarlockLord]

What? Don't hate on the party Mage. . . or the mage'll hate on you! w00t!

I voted Fiendish Codex I, as we already have to many d*** monster books.

 

[Seeker95]

I voted Complete Mage. Redundant Book.

 

[Ron]

I voted Red Hand of Doom based on the fact that it's an adventure, not a sourcebook. I love good adventures, but I'm far more fond of good sourcebooks.

Still, it is the first good adventure released by WotC to D&D 3.X, it should be worth of something, especially considering that these sourcebooks, with the possible exception of the fiendish ones, are rather weak.