2006 WotC D&D Product Survivor - Round 14 (Final Five)

[delericho]

it is the first good adventure released by WotC to D&D 3.X

First of 3.5, surely? Certainly the first good one for years. But "The Sunless Citadel", the first D&D module for 3.0, remains a very good adventure.

 

[brehobit]

First of 3.5, surely? Certainly the first good one for years. But "The Sunless Citadel", the first D&D module for 3.0, remains a very good adventure.

Humm....

No.

Sunless Citadel has Meepo as a redeeming feature, and a bit of kobold negotiation, but that's it. It is otherwise a dungeon crawl.

Red Hand of Doom is much more than a dungeon crawl. I'd say it is the best product of the year for WoTC. Not perfect, but very good.

Mark

 

[Nyeshet]

It has gotten to the point where it is hard to make a choice, as all remaining are quite excellent. Despite that, this time I vote for Red Hand of Doom. Well designed, it is still an adventure module. That is the only reason I am voting for it, in fact, as it in all other respects is utterly deserving of being in the top five.

 

[Agamon]

It has gotten to the point where it is hard to make a choice, as all remaining are quite excellent. Despite that, this time I vote for Red Hand of Doom. Well designed, it is still an adventure module. That is the only reason I am voting for it, in fact, as it in all other respects is utterly deserving of being in the top five.

I agree. These are all pretty good books (even though I only own one) and hard to vote for. I went woth RHoD for the same reason.

 

[Elrendyl]

I have to go with the Fiendish Codex books... how many creatures can there be??? If you took all the monster books and used less than half the monsters, you would have no room for the player races! Much better to keep things simple and have a few quality monsters instead of 15 million reptialian races.

 

[the Jester]

That's a hard choice to make. Those are all great products.

 

[Psion]

I have to go with the Fiendish Codex books... how many creatures can there be???

This, ladies and gentlemen, is why I am not comfortable trying to vote out books I don't own.

FCI & II are far from just "creature books".

 

[Ron]

First of 3.5, surely? Certainly the first good one for years. But "The Sunless Citadel", the first D&D module for 3.0, remains a very good adventure.

I read this one but, I am sorry, I found it pretty boring. The fact I read it about a year and a half after the release of D&D 3.0 probably took any sense of wonder that I guess impressed the early readers.

I didn't liked any of the adventure path modules and just found Return to the Temple of Elemental Evil one of the worst modules I ever played. I cannot comment on the City of Spiders, though.

 

[Angel Tarragon]

Red Hand of Domm. I dislike buying adventures from WotC. I have a subscription to Dungeon.