Thunderfoot
Hero
Which goes back to my suggestions - remember that this person is just starting out, give him the good tools to use, teach the aspect of research and role-play.GoodKingJayIII said:I would normally agree, but if you're mentoring a new DM I'd stick with what you know first. There's plenty of Greek-themed stuff out there.
Heck, you don't even need to buy anything. Take some time to brainstorm a Sparta-like Empire, do some research, throw in a little world-building, and you're all set!
As for the comment about no realism, what I have found inthe 27 years that I have DMed is that using realism as a 'backdrop' causes the unrealistic style of play that the players bring to the table ('epic/heroic characters) creates a much better storyline and memorable campaign archs than the typical 'cartoonish' everyone is a superhero themes, if they were, then why are the characters special? Its about balance folks, if you've never seen it, you wouldn't understand, but once you have, you ache in your soul to see it again.
I'd think you could do an Iliad type thing, perhaps with Persian gods and demons joining the battle (qv Herodotus), since their King & generals tended to stay safely back, or you can have the Immortals be super-warriors of comparable stature to the Sparteatei, but I'd think dialing it down a bit would work better - I'd generally peg Sparteatei at ca F3 (helots & perioeci as War 1-3), Persian Immortals at F1-F3, most of the 600,000 strong (Thucydides says 6 million AIR) Persian army as Com-1s, or War-1s at best, Thespian or Theban citizen hoplites as well-armoured War-2-3s, other light Greek troops as War1 -2. Your hero PCs can be 6th level or so with Leadership feat.