I use a combination of different minis for my various games.
Player Minis
Player minis get a ton of special attention. I consider it to be very important for players to have a perfect mini to represent their character, so I work with them to design a look that fits their mental concept, and then I start digging through various minis lines to find something appropriate.
If I find something perfect, I'll just paint it.
Usually minis require at least at least some conversion work, though-- I'll do weapon swaps, or sculpt on details and custom heads.
Other times, there's just no appropriate mini anywhere, so I sculpt the models from scratch.
My
superhero PCs' minis follow the same lines-- most are converted and repainted Heroclix, but when I run into something that just doesn't have a good base (like Code Monkey in that pic), it gets scratch sculpted.
Monster Minis
Players need nice minis because it's a part of how they bond with the character; but nobody really cares what the bad guys look like (since they usually only live a few hours at most), so they get FAR less time and effort than hero minis.
For my regular D&D game, I use whatever I can scrounge:
- I have about 40 D&D minis, and I've just bought 140 more from TrollAndToad.com (they'll be arriving this week, I'm quite excited)
- I've got 25-30 random Reaper metal minis-- zombies, Kobolds, and bigger things like ogres and trolls. I paint these VERY quickly-- base colours (usually 2 to 3 colours per mini), and then a quick GW wash for shading. It only takes me about 10 minutes per figure-- I don't really care what they end up looking like.
- I buy some GW minis off of other people when I see lots for sale-- zombies, skeletons, and the like. If I need to paint them, they get the same half-assed paintjob as the Reaper minis.
- I also buy some of the pre-painted Reaper minis (which are plastic casts of some of their stock metal models). They're very similar in quality to D&D minis, but since they're non-random, they're much more useful for bulking out certain monster types.
Bad guys for my 4e superhero game are much tougher. Heroclix tend to be very specifically a certain character, so they're a harder sell in my homebrew world. Thus, I've forsaken the use of minis entirely for the bad guys my heroes fight, and instead make
paper standees. I draw all the art, then print them two-sided and cut them out. I hot-glue pennies to the bottom to help them stand up.