4E Stuff in General

[Mustrum_Ridcully]

Well, I pointed out a couple of example of threads that are clearly about rules, and not general discussion. I won't reiterate them.

However, more constructively, at what point does the line between Rules and General Discussion blur? If I wrote a post discussing the power system in 4E, that's pretty clearly about 4E rules, even if it isn't about a specific rules question.

Even if you limit 4E Rules to direct rules questions, why then does Pathfinder get a rules discussion board, and every other game gets the General Rules Discussion board, doesn't D&D have one? I would think D&D would be the one board that should have one. Also, while the 4E Rules board description says other 4E discussion should be in General, the General description says system-neutral stuff.

(ugh, battery dying, will post more later, sorry)

I tend to go with Morrus here*. Don't overthink it. Concentrate on the message board discussion, not on the meta-discussion.

(Of course I do, he is the frigging owner of this message board!)

 

[freyar]

Just wanted to check if the update got the "move thread" buttons working again, 'cause there are quite a few threads in general that probably ought to be in rules or houserules forums. 3e and 4e both. I just don't want to start reporting any if there's nothing to do about it.