GMSkarka said:Yup...and as a pulp collector and obsessive, using the word "pulp" as a genre descriptor bugs the living heck out of me. Pulp is a medium, not a genre--it would be like referring to something as being in the "television genre". Pulp was a medium that contained many distinct genres: Hero pulps, science fiction, mystery, wierd menace, westerns, horror, espionage, etc. etc.
But, when in Rome....
![]()
A sensible position.
Me, I think that "pulp" is at the very least a "pseudo-genre" for RPG purposes, just because there are various products that pulls the disperate elements from the various kinds of pulps [and cliffhanger serials, and modern homages to all of the above] together into a single setting. "Forbidden Kingdoms" did some of this, as did Polyhedron's "Pulp Heroes."
Kinda like a comic book universe...despite the differences in tone and content between, say, Garth Ennis' "Punisher" and Mark Waid's "Fantastic Four," both take place in the same NYC circa 2004.
"Sam Spade and the Shadow and Tarzan versus Fu Manchu and the Nazi occultist robots" may not have cropped up in the actual pulps, but it makes a hell of an RPG session, and "pulp" is as good a name for it as any.
Last edited: