Adjustment to Craft Points and Crafting

[Knight Otu]

As for #3, if that helps your decisions - I've talked with Andy Collins, and apparently, the side effects that Xael pointed out were unintended, and the costs should not be higher than normal magic items.

 

[nimisgod]

Oh, in that case, YES for #3 as well.

 

[Bront]

Cool.

So, for #2, should we think of a good time period? I noticed a lot of abstaining, and I realize that #2 is a bit, well, vague.

 

[Rystil Arden]

Cool.

So, for #2, should we think of a good time period? I noticed a lot of abstaining, and I realize that #2 is a bit, well, vague.

I'd suggest splitting #2 up into two separate points, as even for those leery of allowing crafting to go on at the inn based on real-world time, I'd guess (though I could be wrong) that there would be little opposition to officially giving a thumbs up for crafting without craft points on an adventure if you have the time, particularly since the craft point system never meant to disallow that sort of crafting in the first place.

 

[Knight Otu]

I'll amend my vote on #2:
Yes on crafting during an adventure.
Abstain on the rest.

 

[Bront]

Ok, Created 2A, and 2B (KO voted for 2A)

 

[El Jefe]

I can vote YES on 2A, Crafting During an Adventure.

 

[Patlin]

Change #1-- No feat for masterwork item creation. I vote YES.

Change 2A -- Inside adventures, the normal d20 crafting rules apply, as the DM controls time inside the adventure. I vote YES.

Change 2B -- I don't understand this bit, so I abstain. The craft point system still works the same as previously betweeen adventures, or am I confused?

Change 3 -- I am slightly confused, but I vote YES. This should cause the total creation cost of an item to be the same in gp and xp as the normal d20 rules, right? The distiction between material costs and other costs had always perplexed me, I must admit.

If hypothetical scroll A costs 25 gp market price, I am happy enough knowing it costs 12.5 gp and 1 xp to craft. I don't really care how the 12.5 gp is divided up between ink, parchment, and other such details.

 

[Knight Otu]

Change 3 -- I am slightly confused, but I vote YES. This should cause the total creation cost of an item to be the same in gp and xp as the normal d20 rules, right?

Right. Some wording weirdness that created extra costs where there shouldn't be.

That leaves only 2B as unapproved for now, I believe. I'll unsticky the thread for now, but discussion on it is always welcome.

 

[Patlin]

That leaves only 2B as unapproved for now, I believe. I'll unsticky the thread for now, but discussion on it is always welcome.

Well, if someone could explain 2b for me, I will change my vote away from abstain.