Sagiro
Rodent of Uncertain Parentage
Consider this scenario:
Combat starts, and the rogue has the highest initiative. He's less than 30' away from an enemy wizard, and announces he's readying an action to fire his bow at the wizard if she casts a spell.
The wizard starts to cast a spell at the rogue, and the rogue fires. Is the wizard considered flat-footed, and thus vulnerable to sneak-attack damage? On the one hand, the wizard hasn't yet gone, and so should be considered flat-footed. On the other hand, the wizard must have at least started casting the spell in order to trigger the readied action, and that seems to contradict the notion that the wizard is caught off guard at the moment of the attack. Reading the PH I'd have to say that by the rules, it's a sneak-attack. Has this ever been clarified by WotC? I'd be interested in hearing opinions. Thanks!
-Sagiro
Combat starts, and the rogue has the highest initiative. He's less than 30' away from an enemy wizard, and announces he's readying an action to fire his bow at the wizard if she casts a spell.
The wizard starts to cast a spell at the rogue, and the rogue fires. Is the wizard considered flat-footed, and thus vulnerable to sneak-attack damage? On the one hand, the wizard hasn't yet gone, and so should be considered flat-footed. On the other hand, the wizard must have at least started casting the spell in order to trigger the readied action, and that seems to contradict the notion that the wizard is caught off guard at the moment of the attack. Reading the PH I'd have to say that by the rules, it's a sneak-attack. Has this ever been clarified by WotC? I'd be interested in hearing opinions. Thanks!
-Sagiro
Last edited: