Can You Recommend Fantasy-Detective Works with a Film Noir Flavor?

Here is one

"Gun with Occasional Music" by Jonathan Lethem. I love that book, but it does have more of a sci-fi bent to it than fantasy.

A kangaroo is the main villian, leading to some of the best and hilarious noir lines I have ever read at the same time.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Dead Witch Walking and The Good, the Bad, & the Undead both by Kim Harrison.

Not quite noir - Ghosts in the Snow by Tamar Siler

For a pretty amusing bad attempt try Dragon Precinct. Cops in a fantasy city... does not work all that well as either a mystery or as a fantasy. :( But good in places.

The Auld Grump
 

I just read one of the Harry Dresden novels and I really wasn't very impressed. If you are looking for "Fantasy Detective in Modern World", the Laurel K Hamilton books are much better. The Dresden book struck me as being a "Derleth Cthulhu" story, it apes the form and the style, while completely missing the flavor and quality.
 

The Dresden Files RPG is coming, as well. I just started the latest book, Dead Heat, and it's shaping up to be just as good as the rest of the series. I find it tremendously amusing that Harry games regularly with a bunch of vigilante werewolves.

Stalking the Unicorn is very good, as well.
The Hawk and Fisher books are fairly well done. Dragon Precinct.. can't get into it.
Green's Nightside books are very good; haven't read the latest, though.

You might want to look at the Madrox trade paperback. Jamie Madrox, formerly Madrox the Multiple Man who was Moira's assistant, has set himself up as a private eye in NYC. He uses his ability to create duplicates of himself to solve crimes.

Similarly, the Powers series deals with police detectives in a world of superheroes.

Tanya Huff's Victory Nelson series; Toronto policewoman Victoria Nelson must suddenly deal with a series of horrifc encounters, each based on a classic monster.

P N Elrod's Vampire series: Blood on the Water, Fire in the Blood, Art in the Blood, A Chill in the Blood, The Vampire Files and more.
 

Jonathan Lethem is a fantastic writer; I highly recommend his work, including "Gun with Occasional Music".

Abraxas isn't so much a novel to read as it is a novel to lay down and avoid--but it fits your criteria perfectly, and it won the World Fantasy Award, so obviously either it's to some folks' tastes or the author is a master blackmailer. Don't say I didn't warn you, though.

Daniel
 

I want to second Night Watch. A great Fantasy novel with a detective motif.

But for private investigator novels, nothing is better than Glen Cook's Garret series.

Check out the latest Garret novel, Whispering Nickel Idols (Came out in May).
 

Remove ads

Top