The crit applies penalties as well as bonuses to rolls. Minimum damage is one.
OK, let's agree that creatures with no reach can never take AoO's (I saw somewhere that they threaten their own square, so that's why I gave it the AoO). In that case, the horse can run around the arena and the eladrin can't take an AoO when it catches up.
So we agree to a draw so Evilhalfling can take over?
OK, let's agree that creatures with no reach can never take AoO's (I saw somewhere that they threaten their own square, so that's why I gave it the AoO). In that case, the horse can run around the arena and the eladrin can't take an AoO when it catches up.
So we agree to a draw so Evilhalfling can take over?