[/QUOTE]
Mustrum_Ridcully said:
But there is already a bad BAB progression. We have 1/2, 3/4 and 1 per level. That is sufficient.
sufficient for DND maybe, frankly i think its insufficient even there, but not IMo or IMX for scifi. The aging scientist expert on alien life forms should not have to be a better marksman than a young trained marine in order to have good enough skill at his specialty.
One of the drawbacks i found in Stargate D20 (while its a great game!) was the results of everyone having at least 1/2 BAB and other things resulted in things like the aging 60+ year old scientist (Ernie littlefield) being able to beat up major kowalski (marine in his prime) because of ernies higher level giving him so much BAB, hit points, saves and such.
having seen the show and the same characters, the notion that ernie could take out kowalski in a melee was laughable.
In DND this same sort of thing falls thru when you start looking at commoners and sages.
having more diversity in stat progressions allows for MORE diverse character options and for me T20's expanded diversity makes sense.
Mustrum_Ridcully said:
I played T20 for a session,
a WHOLE session?!?
Wow!
Mustrum_Ridcully said:
and I didn´t really like that, nor most of the rule changes they did.
While i did not like all of them, and definitely did not like some of what they kept, we disagree here.
Mustrum_Ridcully said:
If you don´t want combat an integral part of your game (and rules), don´t use D20.
"integral" does not equal "predominant". Almost all of my games have combat as an integral part, and some characters are usually bad at it. Then again, when the other integral parts of the game (like social challenges, scientific challenges and exploration and the like) get the spotlight, those combat oriented characters usually aren't very good at those either.
D20 is a lot more robust than just its combat system. heck, frankly, its combat system is one of the areas where i think the system rates weakest.
clearly you did not have a favorable experience with t20 in your one and only session... but from my experience, while its not just like DND but with space ships, the changes seemed to fit the setting and style quite well.