D&D General Did You "Return" because of some Edition of D&D?

I returned to gaming after a hiatus with the following current edition of D&D

  • Original D&D

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • AD&D 1E

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • B/X or BECMI

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • AD&D 2E

    Votes: 3 2.2%
  • 3E or 3.5E

    Votes: 21 15.3%
  • 4E

    Votes: 15 10.9%
  • 5E

    Votes: 42 30.7%
  • Other: I did but the edition wasn't current at the time.

    Votes: 3 2.2%
  • No: I did leave gaming for a while but returned due to an entirely different game.

    Votes: 4 2.9%
  • No: I never left.

    Votes: 48 35.0%

Just curiosity.

Did you stop gaming for a while (years, i mean) and then return to the hobby because of some edition of D&D? If so, which edition? Note that if you did but not when that edition was current, please answer "other" and explain in the comments.

Also, it shouldn't need to be said, but PLEASE no Edition Warring. Your battles are over, my friend. Find peace now.
I had some years in the mid-late 1990s of little or no gaming. I moved to London in June 2000 just as 3e was coming out... been playing ever since, apart from a year when my son was born.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Sort of, twice.

The first time was when I left high school and went to university. This led to a hiatus from gaming entirely, and then a long time playing World of Darkness. When 3e was announced, this led to me dusting off 2nd Ed for one last campaign, and then moving to 3e on release.

Later, I skipped 4e almost entirely. I didn't really stop gaming that time, but stayed with 3.5e. But I was definitely seeing the warts in that system by the end! 5e probably stopped me just giving up... for now.
 

After playing B/X and 1st Edition from 1982 to 1989, I stopped playing RPGs altogether. Partly because I didn’t feel like re-buying rulebooks for 2nd Edition, but mostly because my gaming group scattered to the winds when we hit college.

Fast-forward to 2014, when I started seeing articles online about how a new edition of D&D was coming out, and it looked pretty good. I ordered the PHB on a whim and liked it, so I ordered the MM and some dice, then the DMG when that came out.

I didn’t actually find a table to play at until 2016, and that group broke up after about a year and a half. I finally switched over to online play earlier this year.

*I remember being tempted by the 4th Edition rulebooks a few years earlier when I saw them at a chain bookstore (remember those?) But at the time, the $120 price tag was more than I felt like spending on a lark. The next time I made my way to the store, the number of rulebooks had jumped from three to six, and I lost interest.
 

I stopped playing when 4e came out. That had as much to do with getting married as anything else, but it's also true that I disagreed with 4e's changes and omissions relative to 3.x. but I never stopped thinking and reading about the game.

When the Next playtest started a few years later I was interested and downloaded all the playtest stuff. I really liked what I saw (and I'm still disappointed that a lot of the stuff didn't make the final cut), and I dove back in full-scale when the 5e stuff was released.

Ironically, I play DCC almost exclusively now.
 


I took a few years off here and there but consider myself in the never left column. I always kept abreast of the game and editions as they came along after 1E AD&D
 

Did you stop gaming for a while (years, i mean) and then return to the hobby because of some edition of D&D? If so, which edition? Note that if you did but not when that edition was current, please answer "other" and explain in the comments.
I returned to gaming in 2005 after a hiatus of 6 years when i got my daughters. The current edition of D&D was 3.5 but i went back to AD&D 2nd edition, since it was the one i knew better. You never forget your first love as we say! ;)
 

Stopped playing 1e in around '88 for Warhammer Fantasy and other games (Star Frontiers, Paranoia, a friend's homebrew system, and others). Stopped playing TTRPGs altogether when I went to college. Got back into gaming again when I moved back to the US and my hometown where I still had some friends from highschool in the mid 2000s, but that was almost all board games. I was interested in running D&D but never got beyond browsing through some 4e and Pathfinder books that really didn't grab me. When the 5e PHP came out I browsed it at a FLGS and was immediately hooked.
 

I never took a hiatus from RPGs except for not having a group back in parts of the 80s.

I have had groups come back together that were on hiatus. Those often were because someone had a new RPG they pitched to us that was enough to overcome whatever scheduling/burnout/other RL issue that broke the group. None of them were D&D - if we were interested enough in playing D&D we would have been playing D&D.
 

I returned because in 2018 a bunch of my students dragged me into this new campaign they started (apparently when Critical Role hit Youtube), so my jump was from original AD&D straight into 5e. In retrospect, it looks like I missed a lot.
 

Remove ads

Top