Dragonlance Dragonlance Lawsuit Dismissed Without Prejudice

The recent lawsuit brought against D&D publishers Wizards of the Coast by Dragonlance authors Margaret Weis and Tracy Hickman has been voluntarily dismissed without prejudice.

When a lawsuit is dismissed with prejudice, it means that the plaintiff cannot bring the issue back to court. When -- as in this case -- it is dismissed without prejudice, the plaintiff can try again.

In this case it was voluntarily dismissed by Weis & Hickman. We can only guess why; perhaps a settlement occurred? In any case, Margaret Weis tweeted, thanking people for their support, and hinting at exciting news to come.

"Pursuant to Rule 41(a)(1)(A)(i) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Plaintiff Margaret Weis, LLC and Tracy Hickman hereby gives notice that the above-captioned action is voluntarily dismissed as to Wizards of the Coast LLC, without prejudice. Defendant Wizards of the Coast LLC has not filed an answer or motion for summary judgment, no proceedings or discovery have been undertaken as to these claims, and this action is not subject to any federal statute which would preclude the dismissal of this action under Rule 41(a)(1)(A)(i)."

 

[whimsychris123]

Okay, I have decided that Dragonlance is going to be the next released setting with novel releases, and I refuse to believe otherwise. I mean this tongue-in-cheek, but it does make me excited that Dragonlance still might have some life in it!

 

[Waller]

That's how I first read the headline. Adding "Voluntarily" to the headline would make it clearer.

And then you read the post.

 

[Demetrios1453]

Okay, I have decided that Dragonlance is going to be the next released setting with novel releases, and I refuse to believe otherwise. I mean this tongue-in-cheek, but it does make me excited that Dragonlance still might have some life in it!

Maybe not "next", but it does seem to point towards a DL release or releases sometime relatively soon!

 

[Olgar Shiverstone]

Sounds encouraging.

//

Chris Pine as Bupu.

 

[imagineGod]

Most of the lay public would read "dismissed" as thrown out of court, so good to hear the legaleese explained as a settlement between both parties instead.

So does this mean we get Dragonlance for D&D 5th Edition? If yes, I need to cancel other other pre-orders for different projects used to buy my time.

 

[Waller]

Most of the lay public would read "dismissed" as thrown out of court

Who are these imaginary people? Everybody here has read the post, right? If they can’t be bothered to read the post, then that’s on them.

 

[Ender Xer0]

So, just FYI, this is what it looks like when an out-of-court settlement is reached. The ability to re-file the lawsuit is there just in case one of the sides (ie, WOTC) doesn't abide by the settlement.

Source: more law school tuition than I like to remember

 

[Waller]

So, just FYI, this is what it looks like when an out-of-court settlement is reached. The ability to re-file the lawsuit is there just in case one of the sides (ie, WOTC) doesn't abide by the settlement.

Source: more law school tuition than I like to remember

You took all that law school to repeat the OP?

 

[Ath-kethin]

Yes! Maybe now we'll finally get Dragonlance with all the orcs, warforged, drow elves, and other Wizards IP they always wished we would start wanting!

 

[muglinimic]

No one's mentioned that Joe Manganiello wink winked about having unreleased official stats for a Dragonlance race in a video the other day.

 

[Morrus]

No one's mentioned that Joe Manganiello wink winked about having unreleased official stats for a Dragonlance race in a video the other day.

Yes they have. You did!

 

[wingsandsword]

Yeah, they settled.

Margaret Weis re-tweeted an announcement that they'd settled the suit.

 

[Umbran]

You took all that law school to repeat the OP?

Mod Note:

Try being about 7 levels less personally insulting and snarky in the future, because that's not acceptable.

 

[Umbran]

What it means is maybe a Beadle & Grimms legendary Dragonlance box!

Dangit! Well, there goes that money. :/

 

[Voadam]

And then you read the post.

I did. You are unlikely to see any responses in this thread from people who read the headline, take the same initial impression, and move on without reading the full post.

A headline that can be taken to imply the opposite of what it tries to communicate can be improved.

 

[Blue]

My suggestion? MW&TH creating a new world with total creative freedom, something like a spiritual succesor. If this project works, then WotC buys it as a new D&D world.

The issue was that they have already put in over a year of work on what they are doing now, which in the original lawsuit they claimed at millions of dollars of value - which sounds like established work with expected royalties. A settlement to do something else that does not fulfill that would probably not be acceptable.

 

[MidnightBlue]

I'm still bummed we never saw Dragonlance 4E.

 

[Minigiant]

Sounds like an out-of-court settlement. Draconians, here we come.

 

[Abstruse]

I'm still bummed we never saw Dragonlance 4E.

Blame the switch to the Essentials release method for that. Dragonlance was going to be the next setting after Ravenloft (which work on that got repurposes into the Shadowfell thing they did) with a complete reboot of the setting and a new trilogy of novels starting with a brand new version of Dragons of Autumn Twilight written by Jim Butcher (Dresden Files, Codex Alera). He was going to have Tasselhoff not have the dagger he "borrowed" during their first fight on the way to the Inn of the Last Home, which means Flint would've been injured and the three of them delayed getting to the Inn until after Goldmoon and Riverwind arrived and all the ripple effect changes from there. He also had new concepts for the characters, like Raistlin inspired by Dr. Gregory House from the TV show House. The deal fell apart when Butcher learned that Weis and Hickman hadn't been consulted so he pulled out, and shortly after the 4e line was restructured and the release schedule scrapped.

 

[Von Ether]

Again, kill fees (where the writer gets some compensation even if the project is killed) were invented for a reason. And for projects as big as WotC tackles, kill fees can be a good insurance policy (since the fee would have probably been smaller than the settlement they are now locked into.)

And high profile personalities like W and H should have merited a kill fee. In many ways, the ttRPG industry is young and it still look to other industries for tools to use.