Exploring Eberron: Forge of the Artificer

Third time seems to be the charm for the artificer in Eberron: Forge of the Artificer. The book is described as a supplement to Eberron: Rising from the Last War and offers new character options, new campaign models, and new vehicle rules for Eberron.
DnD-eberron-forge-of-the-artificer cover.jpg

Exploring Eberron: Forge of the Artificer

This book is described as a supplement to Eberron: Rising from the Last War and offers new character options, new campaign models, and new vehicle rules for Eberron.

The titular artificers, one of the iconic aspects of Eberron along with the Warforged, are a tricky class. It needs to be cool, not horribly complicated to manage, and shouldn’t be so powerful it’s a campaign breaker. While Eberron fans were thrilled when the setting got its first official 5E book (as opposed to the digital only release, The Wayfinders Guide to Eberron, which I’m not counting in regard to the artificer because the original digital document didn’t include it. The artificer only showed up in later updates in the appendix), the ERftLW version didn’t quite hit the mark with some fans.

The artificer’s appearance in Tasha’s Cauldron of Everything was mostly to set up the class for use in any D&D campaign setting and give it an expanded spell list that incorporated the new spells in TCoE. It also added a new artificer subclass, the armorer, to join the alchemist, artillerist, and battlesmith. I liked the builds for the 5E versions of the artificer even though magical tinkering isn’t my jam, but the newest version has some zest, and one thing that’s odd.

Battle-Smith-inquisitive-on-the-hunt Kuno.jpg

A Revised Artificer​

How much importance does the new artificer get in EFotA? It gets its own chapter, with other character options detailed in another chapter.

Despite that amount of space, the entry is surprisingly skimpy on flavor text to provide a sense of how the artificer fits into the setting if the reader is new to Eberron. What we do get is accurate—"Masters of invention, Artificers use ingenuity and magic to unlock extraordinary capabilities in objects. They see magic as a complex system waiting to be decoded and then harnessed in their spells and inventions" —but rather flat. I expected a little more flavor text, but I’m also a sucker for world-building material.

As with the prior version, artificers cast spells through their tools. A lot of the basics are the same, like hit dice, but carrying over the use of simple weapons is odd. While that’s not too unusual for the prior iterations when firearms were only an option in the 2014 DMG, it feels weird here. The 2024 PHB moved muskets and pistols to the ranged martial weapons table, so why are artificers limited to simple weapons? An artificer with a cool, magical firearm seems like a natural. The class could have at least made an exception for firearms while excluding other ranged martial weapons.

Other than that, the changes are rather cool or give some power boosts without entirely breaking everything. For example, artificers replace spells after a long rest, which is handy.

The first level feature Tinker’s Magic offers some fun options, especially for those who embrace creative options. First, you automatically get the mending cantrip separate from the other two cantrips gained at first level. Even better, a magic action can be used to create one item in an unoccupied space within 5 feet of yourself. The options are limited to the items on a list but they range from baskets, bedrolls, and bells to shovels, torches, and vials, with 31 options total.

Level 2 Replicate Magic replaces Infuse Magic and potentially gives your low-level group a really nice boost. The feature allows the artificer to learn four types of magic item plans. With those plans, after finishing a long rest, the artificer can create one or two different magic items based on the plans they know. If the item requires attunement, the artificer can attune to it as soon as it’s created. The book recommends creating the items bag of holding, cap of water breather, sending stones, and wand of the war mage, but other options include a +1 weapon and a +1 shield, which is pretty awesome for a low level group.

Another fun option comes with the Level 6 Magic Item Tinker, which lets you, among other options, drain the magic from an item you created with Replicate Magic Item, which causes it to disappear and give you a fresh spell slot. That can be very useful if handled strategically.

The new artificer has more features, of course, but if I delve into everything in EFotA deeply, this will be a 10,000 word review. Suffice to say that the cartographer subclass is a worthy addition, and the new artificer spell, Homunculus Servant, makes sense and fills a previous gap.

Personally, I don’t love artificers in general because they can be complicated to play and magical tinkering isn’t my thing, but I do like the revised build here. A clever player could come up with some ingenious options if they use this build to think strategically and outside of the box. Isn’t that one of the elements of a good artificer?

artificer-and-creation-first-meeting Leroy Steinmann.jpg

Character Options​

The artificer isn’t the only one character option to get an upgrade/expansion. A new species, the Khoravar, are a bridge between elves and humans while having distinct communities from those of humans or elves. Just don’t call them “half-elves”.

Some existing Eberron species were tweaked. For example, Shifters (a.k.a. “were-touched”) get Bestial Instincts, which allows them to channel the beast within to gain proficiency in Acrobatics, Athletics, Intimidation or Survival. Shifting is a bonus action that allows them to take on a bestial appearance.

For Warforged, Integrated Protection is simplified to a +1 Armor Class bonus and any armor worn cannot be removed against their will as long as they are alive. More importantly, players can use either the EFotA or the ERftLW version of the species so if you prefer the older version, it’s still an option.

For those who like Dragonmarks, there’s a lot to explore. EFotA has 28 Dragonmark feats, and 14 of the 16 backgrounds are related to dragonmarks. These backgrounds are the only way to get a dragonmark feat at level one. The two non-dragonmark backgrounds are Archaeologist and Inquisitive.

strider-airship Sean Macdonald.jpg

Airships & Bastions​

One of the definite bonuses is its chapter on elemental airships. What would a magic steampunk setting be without some form of airship? EFotA has everything you need to know operating, boarding, maneuvering, staffing, repairing airships, combat (of course), and dealing with crashes.

It also deals with monster tactics because, after all, dragons, rocs, and other flying creatures might find elemental airships a threat or interesting—or the delivery method for tasty treats (its crew). So there’s also a section on what characters can do during airship combat.

Three elemental airships are detailed and statted out. That’s followed by info on how to upgrade elemental airships. Charts for airship travel conditions, environmental hazards, and random airship encounters round out the chapter.

I really liked the bastion options in the 2024 Dungeon Masters Guide, and was happy to find new bastion options in Forgotten Realms: Heroes of Faerun. We get more here in EFotA , which makes perfect sense. I’m guessing future books will also include them where the setting inspires fresh options.

One thing the Eberron version notes is that while the DMG assumes a fixed location, it doesn’t have to be that way, pending DM approval and two requirements—a mobile bastion must be a vehicle of some sort and one of the special features must involve propulsion. In Eberron, that means a bastion could be a regular ship, an airship, or a lightning rail cart.

The Artificer’s Forge is a roomy bastion that includes two magewright hirelings skilled in creating magic items. Construct Forge bastions are vast in size, and the constructs made in it count as Bastion Defenders. Even a museum can be a bastion, which is perfect for research and storing relics.

A Dragonmark Outpost is, obviously, for those in a dragonmarked house and comes with a house agent hireling who will be a go-between for the players and their superiors in the dragonmarked house. An Inquisitive Agency is an office that’s a branch office for a larger agency or is an office for an agency you control. Examples of the former include Information Acquisition and Karr’Aashta’s Investigations, which are detailed in the chapter on Inquisitives in Sharn. The hireling for an Inquisitive Agency bastion is a secretary with extensive helpful contacts.

The Kundarak Vault is “cramped” because it’s an extra-dimensional space within your bastion that can be accessed from other spaces, using them for trade good storage and such. A Manifest Zone is a bastion infused with the planar energy of one of Eberron’s planes of existence. You pick the plane when it’s created.

The Lyrandar Helm allows a mobile bastion within an elemental ship or airship to move. Its hireling is dragonmarked from the House of Lyrandar. A Navigator’s Helm is similar but for sailing ships. An Orien Helm is for lightning rail carts.

Species-Khoravar Daarken.png

Setting Material​

Sharn has a particular type of adventurer that is a blend of police detective, private investigator, and spy. The EFotA chapter on inquisitives builds upon the information in Eberron: Rising from the Last War. This chapter has inspiration for players, conflict suggestions for players and DMs, and criminal clans that can be adversaries for players.

The chapter on Morgrave Expeditions provides options and inspiration for those who want to embrace more of a pulp adventure style. That can include treasure hunting from Lord ir’Morgrave’s unseemly side or an expedition for the respectable university he founded.

Dragonmarked Intrigue is a chapter for DMs, and players to a lesser degree, if you want a campaign focused on political intrigue, such as Renaissance-era scheming between merchant dynasties. It gives ideas on rival houses, internal tension, and more.

EFotA also includes a bestiary focused on 27 stats for NPCs. They range from Boromar Smuggler and Cannith Artificer to Umbragen Shadow Walker, Vadalis Heir, and Vulkoon Stingblade.

Artificer-working-on-an-unfinished-Warforged.jpg

Should You Buy It?​

If you’re an Eberron fan, you’ll want this book. Since it adds to instead of replaces ERftLW and you can pick the version of the species and artificer you prefer from either book, there’s no downside to adding this book to your library. The chapters on bastions and elemental airships are definitely cool, and the setting information is useful for players and DMs.

I tend to like this phase in an edition anyway—when you start to get additional material for the setting, building upon the one that initially updates the setting for the edition. Eberron: Forge of the Artificer is a better-than-average follow-up so I’m giving it an A-.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Beth Rimmels

Beth Rimmels

Putting out Forge is what I classify as a "least bad" option. It has downsides, but all the alternatives are worse. I absolutely want these player options updated for 5.24e, I don't expect to get that for free, and I'm happier not having to buy a replacement Eberron setting book that's mostly reprints.

We're in new territory where there's been an edition change but it's not a hard break that completely obsoletes the old books. So everyone on both sides is kind of feeling out what happens next. WotC put out a slim book to update a few essentials from Rising while leaving most of it still relevant. If you've been following the UA playtests, they're running updates to a lot of the Xanathar's Guide subclasses through, and we don't know how those will be released yet. Will they put out a Revised Xanathar's Guide? Call it something new? We'll have to wait and see.
I guess the moral of the story here is that people will pay for anything as long as they feel it's catering specifically to them and their preferences and their circumstances, up to defending a business model that currently focuses on lazily rewriting content in an attempt to force players who already own that content to buy it all over again.

It's remarkable, because you'd think people would prefer new content. But that's the kind of target audience 2024 5e is aimed at: the folks who are happy to pay WotC to take away options from other players.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I guess the moral of the story here is that people will pay for anything as long as they feel it's catering specifically to them and their preferences and their circumstances, up to defending a business model that currently focuses on lazily rewriting content in an attempt to force players who already own that content to buy it all over again.

It's remarkable, because you'd think people would prefer new content. But that's the kind of target audience 2024 5e is aimed at: the folks who are happy to pay WotC to take away options from other players.
Yes I will pay for something if it caters to my preferences and circumstances… why wouldn’t I? Or rather. Why wouldn’t you?

It’s ok to be upset that WotC isn’t catering to your needs. I just don’t quite understand why you’re surprised when other people buy the stuff when it caters to there’s? Are you expecting solidarity?

The bastions, adventure outlines, new approach to dragon marks and the cartographer are all new works. In fact I will buy it again when it comes out of Foundry. RFTLW isn’t supported on Foundry so this will enable Eberron gaming in that format. Big win.

How did anyone take anything away from you?
 


I mean, AD&D 1e to 2e and D&D 3e to 3.5 both give us some insight on what mixing "editions" can be like. It's not like this is unprecedented.
I came in just after the release of 2e, so I never had any 1e books to compare. But I do remember with 3.5e how it was enough of a clean break that they immediately restarted the class splatbook lines over again with Complete Warrior and its successors.

This time, it's a bit fuzzier. They're immediately going to revise and update things like the Eberron material and the Xanathar's subclasses, but they're still more free with pointing at late 5.14e books like all the player races in MotM.
 

I guess the moral of the story here is that people will pay for anything as long as they feel it's catering specifically to them and their preferences and their circumstances, up to defending a business model that currently focuses on lazily rewriting content in an attempt to force players who already own that content to buy it all over again.

It's remarkable, because you'd think people would prefer new content. But that's the kind of target audience 2024 5e is aimed at: the folks who are happy to pay WotC to take away options from other players.
Yes I care about things that cater to my interests. Why would I care about things that don't interest me?
Nobody is forcing you to buy it or use it. Use the Tasha version if you want. Eberron runs just fine with the 2014 PHB and RftLW. Your books didn't crumble to dust. The legacy options still work on Beyond. Nobody took anything away from you, unless...
Your DM is running 5.24 and they're going to force you to use the FotA updates, aren't they? Your complaint is purely that you don't want to update but your DM is making you and you are blaming WotC for making the book in the first place. Because that's the only thing I can think of that would force you to use it against your will. If that's the case, I recommend talking with your DM or maybe running your own game. It's not WotC's fault people wanted updates and it's certainly not their fault you don't want them. Figure out your table drama and let us who wanted an updated artificer enjoy it.
 

Remove ads

Remove ads

Top