Morrus said:
I must admit that I'm guilty of that. I assumed those PDFs were just a bunch of items (or what-have-you).
As had I. I'm going to have to get more RA products when I have the money.
But, I still recommend the inclusion of IP in all products. Material that cannot be found elsewhere that adds to the value of the product.
Suggested Format
OGC: Stats and basic description.
IP: Expanded description, background and history, item (spell, feat) name, advice on re-naming item (spell, feat).
Example:
IP: Thomas Pyro's Most Efficacious Method for Lighting Fires.
OGC: Stats (haven't figured out what those would be)
OGC: Basic Description; this creates a film of flame of a diameter equal in feet to the caster's level. The film will ignite anything that is readily flammable. Such as dry wood and tinder and similar items.
IP: Expanded Description; while meant to be used to light fires - at least that's what Tom said - it has been used to light other things. Structures for example, and on occasion clothing.
IP: Changing the spell; obviously the name has to be changed. "Flame Film" is nice and generic, but not terribly exciting. Same applies to the expanded description. Come up with different ways the spell could be used, and add in a few examples of the unusual ways in which it was used deliberately or by accident.
You still have OGC others can use freely, but you also have IP that gives potential customers a reason to buy the work.