Mike, thanks for taking the time to try and win me over, but past experience has taught me to remain skeptical.
Mike_Lescault said:
The current gleemax.com is a promotional site. We decided to start the promotional site for a few reasons. We wanted to give people a heads up that this was in the works and was coming, so our communities weren't caught by surprise. We also wanted to build up some anticipation since a community orientated site without any critical mass of community will have a tough time starting out.
It worries me that there is a concern about 'surprising' the communities. Is something happening to the exsisting communities?
Mike_Lescault said:
Finally, we wanted to engage the community to take feedback and suggestions on what they'd like to see.
Let's hope the people who weren't driven away by what they found will give you good feedback.
Mike_Lescault said:
With those upsides, we also encounter some downsides. Some people hate the design/art/layout of the page. Some hate the color scheme (and some have trouble reading those colors). Some are frustrated because they're only receiving information and no actual social networking site features. So I think there's plenty of legitimate criticism, I am just not sure that avoiding those problems wouldn't have created even bigger problems.
The problem is, everything you mentioned does major damage to the promotion of the site. It didn't help build anticipation for me, it pretty much killed it.
Seriously, if it wasn't for this thread I would not have returned to Gleemax and saw that it was different. Problem is, I still don't care for what I see.
I will go back (because I actually am a huge WotC fan), but eventually even I will give up on a site that only disappoints...
Mike_Lescault said:
As far as intermittent banning of an issue, I've never seen that on the Wizard's forums.
Are you new? Seriously, talk of katanas was banned within the last year (and that isn't the only thing banned in the past year, I just can't remember what else was). I don't frequent the Wizards boards like I used to, so even I might be missing something.
Mike_Lescault said:
Currently there is search for the forums, only I think it's still limited to a subset of forums users as they make sure it's stable for full search to be turned back on. When the actual gleemax.com site launches, search is something that's being built in from the beginning as we design the architecture, so our goal is to have more robust search capabilities then most other social networking sites out there.
If only a select few can search the site, then there is no search. Let's not confuse the privialges of a few as functionality for the whole site. Actually, talking about the search issue may be the other issue that was banned in the last year.
I am glad to hear that Gleemax will have a functional search though, it would be near useless without it.
Good luck with Gleemax, the concept sounds interesting enough. I just hope it will have value to me.