Goliath Monk: Which Unarmed Damage?

[evilbob]

So if a creature has monkey grip (3.5 version) then a weapon of category one size larger would be "appropriately sized" for them too?

Technically, he did say "without penalty," and Monkey Grip gives you a -2 penalty (I think it's for wielding a weapon inappropriately sized, actually). But yeah, Monkey Grip works a lot differently than the racial feature, and I would not think it would be treated the same.

 

[UltimaGabe]

Have you not seen the threads on that subject? Some of us think that they quite clearly don't. Not that I rreally want to debate that again.


glass.

Quite a few people still think that they don't qualify for INA- but the issue was already clarified in one of the FAQs last year. (The only debate was whether or not a feat was an "effect" for purposes of the monk's unarmed improvement- and the FAQ clearly stated that YES, a feat IS an effect.) Anyone who still claims that monks don't qualify for INA is blatantly ignoring a rules clarification, and therefore have no right to argue. If I decide to ignore the Power Attack prerequisite for Cleave, do I get to argue that Cleave doesn't require Power Attack?

It's been clarified. A lot of people may not agree with it, but the rules have been stated. There shouldn't be any argument anymore.

 

[Kmart Kommando]

If I decide to ignore the Power Attack prerequisite for Cleave, do I get to argue that Cleave doesn't require Power Attack?

Actually, my Crusader in my Friday game has Cleave but not Power Attack.

Stone Power FTW!