OOC: Boy, I don't know where the 147 came from. 116 is indeed the correct number, and if you had asked me away from the board what his hp was, that's what I would have said. The chill touch was 6+2+8 damage. [Edit: Ah, the 147 came from adding 16 to Stonemaker's hp prior to the attack round]
PJSlavner
[sblock]
Hmm the tail slap gets 1.5xStr on a 29Str (+8 dmg -> +12 dmg), plus d8 gives us a base of 13 to 20. It does appear right in a blind gap, doesn't it. And yet it appears twice in that round - the AoO before PA and was part of the full attack. Neither was a critical, because I would have called that out. I'm pretty sure that the "solid blow" description was an '8' on the d8, but I haven't kept records of all of the rolls thru the history. I'd bet that I didn't apply DR to the AoO attack.
[/sblock]
Folks, I'm going to hold this until I can dig out what's wrong with some of the numbers, as raised by PJSlavner. Feel free to read his sblock and mine on that. I'm using an Excel sheet I was building as I went and I think that the build-it-as-I-go is part of the problem.