I think their initial releases were a little rocky, but the later stuff has totally come up to speed. The Dragonborn book is totally solid and I played in the DDXP version of Death Dealer --- maps were suitably large enough for us to get our butts kicked.
At first this sounds really good.
$2 sounds good for a 32 page issue. Like "here's 16 bucks, subscribe for the first 2 years" good*. But what's the percentage of ads? I mean, advertising is a reality of magazines, but out of 32 pages, how much will be content?
And how self contained is the content? It's Goodman's magazine so pimping one's own stuff should be expected, but paying for something that is mostly excerpts and previews of upcoming releases is a whole 'nother thing.
Well, to put a somewhat different perspective on it, most monthly comic books from DC and Marvel are 32 pages in length (that's counting the ads as pages). DC's books currently retail at $2.99. Marvel's are moving up in price to $3.99 (though I'm not sure if that's for all their comics or just their big ones). Most comics read rather quickly, much faster than a magazine (that's not to disparage their quality; for example, I loved jonrog1's Blue Beetle work, gladly spending the money on it). $2.00 for 32 pages of gaming stuff sounds like a steal to me.
I don't mean to be rude or anything, but are we having a debate over the relative value of a product priced at $2. Really? When was the last time there was any gaming product priced like that?
Of course, the first issue of The Dragon was also only 32 pages, and it went on to do pretty well.It's only 32 pages, though--pretty scant for a magazine.