Greatest Character Showdown Round 1 (Results Posted)

[Templetroll]

1. Batman
2. Cthulhu (Urp!)
3. The Cheshire Cat (I had to choose between two I nominated?!? man, that's rough!)
4. The Doctor
5. Wonder Woman
6. Jack Burton
7. Sherlock Holmes
8. Keyser Soze (The Usual Suspects)
9. Captain Jeffrey T. Spaulding (Hooray for Captain Spaulding, the African Explorer!)
10. Raistlin Majere
11. Javert (Les Miserables)
12. 'Dirty' Harry Callahan
13. Indiana Jones
14. Han Solo
15. The Wicked Witch of the West (this was a tough one)
16. Batgirl (Barbara Gordon)
17. Hannibal Lecter
18. Rufus (Kim Possible)
19. Harry Potter
20. Gandalf
21. Dream (The Sandman)
22. Rick Blaine
23. Odysseus
24. Gil Grissom
25. Buffy Summers
26. Gollum
27. Tigger
28. Gregory House (House)
29. Gul Dakat (Star Trek: DS9)
30. James Bond
31. Allan Quartermain
32. Yoda
33. Darth Vader
34. T-1000
35. King Kong
36. Odo (Star Trek: DS9)
37. R2-D2
38. Dr. Spock
39. Horatio Hornblower
40. Doctor Evil
41. Khan
42. Conan
43. Lex Luthor
44. HAL 9000
45. Puff the Magic Dragon
46. The Joker
47. Captain James T. Kirk
48. Professor Moriarty
49. Bugs Bunny
50. Madmartigan (Willow)
51. Elric of Melniboné
52. The Raven
53. Samwise Gamgee
54. Optimus Prime
55. Tarzan
56. Dr. Frankenstein
57. The Lone Ranger
58. Inspector Jacques Clouseau
59. King Lear
60. The Equalizer
61. King Arthur
62. Superman
63. John Crichton (Farscape)
64. Dracula

 

[griff_goodbeard]

1. Batman
2. Cthulhu
3. The Cheshire Cat
4. The Doctor
5. Wonder Woman
6. Jack Burton
7. Sherlock Holmes
8. Keyser Soze (The Usual Suspects)
9. Captain Jeffrey T. Spaulding
10. Raistlin Majere
11. KITT
12. 'Dirty' Harry Callahan
13. Indiana Jones
14. Han Solo
15. The Gray Mouser
16. Batgirl (Barbara Gordon)
17. Hannibal Lecter
18. Rufus (Kim Possible)
19. Samurai Jack
20. Gandalf
21. Dream (The Sandman)
22. Æon Flux
23. Odysseus
24. Hal Jordan
25. Buffy Summers
26. Gollum
27. Tigger
28. Gregory House (House)
29. The Tick
30. The Terminator
31. Det. Vic Mackey
32. Yoda
33. Darth Vader
34. T-1000
35. King Kong
36. Jean Luc-Picard
37. R2-D2
38. Dr. Spock
39. Gaston (Beauty & the Beast)
40. Doctor Evil
41. Khan
42. Conan
43. Bender (Futurama)
44. HAL 9000
45. Ra's al Ghul
46. The Joker
47. Captain James T. Kirk
48. Professor Moriarty
49. Bugs Bunny
50. Madmartigan (Willow)
51. Michael Corleone
52. John Locke (Lost)
53. Samwise Gamgee
54. Optimus Prime
55. Tarzan
56. Snake Plissken
57. The Lone Ranger
58. Inspector Jacques Clouseau
59. BA Baracus (A-Team)
60. The Equalizer
61. Spider-man
62. Superman
63. John Crichton (Farscape)
64. Obi-Wan Kenobi

 

[warlord]

1. Batman
2. Cthulhu
3. Jonah Hex
4. The Doctor
5. Jack Bauer
6. Jack Burton
7. Sherlock Holmes
8. Robin Hood
9. Captain Jeffrey T. Spaulding
10. Raistlin Majere
11. Javert (Les Miserables)
12. 'Dirty' Harry Callahan
13. Indiana Jones
14. Han Solo
15. The Gray Mouser
16. Batgirl (Barbara Gordon)
17. Hannibal Lecter
18. Neither of these deserve to be here.
19. Samurai Jack
20. Tommy Oliver (Power Rangers)
21. Dream (The Sandman)
22. Rick Blaine
23. Odysseus
24. Gil Grissom
25. Buffy Summers
26. Gollum
27. Sepiroth
28. Gregory House (House)
29. The Tick
30. James Bond
31. Det. Vic Mackey vs. Allan Quartermain
32. Yoda
33. Darth Vader
34. Belloq
35. King Kong
36. Jean Luc-Picard
37. R2-D2
38. Mugen
39. Horatio Hornblower
40. The Bride (Kill Bill)
41. Khan
42. Conan
43. Lex Luthor
44. Zorro
45. Ra's al Ghul
46. The Joker
47. Captain Nemo
48. Godzilla
49. Dr. Rodney McKay
50 Madmartigan (Willow)
51. Elric of Melniboné
52. The Raven
53. Danger Mouse
54. Optimus Prime
55. Tarzan
56. Dr. Frankenstein
57. The Lone Ranger
58. Inspector Jacques Clouseau
59. King Lear
60. The Nameless One (Placescape: Torment)
61. Spider-man
62. Superman
63. Captain Malcolm "Mal" Reynolds
64. Obi-Wan Kenobi

 

[Klaus]

1. Batman
2. Cthulhu
3. Jonah Hex
4.
5. Wonder Woman
6. Jack Burton
7. Sherlock Holmes
8. Keyser Soze (The Usual Suspects)
9.
10. Alfred Bester
11. KITT
12. 'Dirty' Harry Callahan
13. Indiana Jones
14. Han Solo
15. The Gray Mouser
16. Batgirl (Barbara Gordon)
17. Hannibal Lecter
18. Rufus (Kim Possible)
19. Samurai Jack
20. Gandalf
21. Dream (The Sandman)
22.
23. Odysseus
24. Hal Jordan
25. Buffy Summers
26. Gollum
27. Tigger
28.
29.
30. James Bond
31. Allan Quartermain
32. Solomon Kane (Robert E. Howard)
33. Captain Jack Sparrow
34. T-1000
35. King Kong
36. Jean Luc-Picard
37. R2-D2
38.
39. Gaston (Beauty & the Beast)
40. Doctor Evil
41. Khan
42. Conan
43. Lex Luthor
44. Zorro
45. Ra's al Ghul
46. The Joker
47. Captain James T. Kirk
48. Professor Moriarty
49. Bugs Bunny
50. Madmartigan (Willow)
51. Elric of Melniboné
52. John Locke (Lost)
53. Samwise Gamgee
54. Optimus Prime
55. Tarzan
56.
57. The Lone Ranger
58. Inspector Jacques Clouseau
59. BA Baracus (A-Team)
60.
61. King Arthur
62. Superman
63. Captain Malcolm "Mal" Reynolds
64. Dracula

 

[OblivionSiege]

1. . Batman
2. Cthulhu
3. Jonah Hex
4. The Doctor
5. Wonder Woman
6. Jack Burton
7. Sherlock Holmes
8. Robin Hood
9. Adrian Monk

11. KITT
12. 'Dirty' Harry Callahan
13. Indiana Jones
14. Han Solo

16. David Xanatos (Gargoyles)

18. Rufus (Kim Possible)
19. Harry Potter
20. Tommy Oliver (Power Rangers)
21. Jin
22. Æon Flux
23. Odysseus
24. Gil Grissom
25. Buffy Summers
26. Gollum
27. Tigger
28. Gregory House (House)
29. Gul Dakat (Star Trek: DS9)
30. The Terminator
31. Allan Quartermain
32. Yoda
33. Captain Jack Sparrow
34. T-1000
35. King Kong
36. Jean Luc-Picard
37. R2-D2
38. Mugen

43. Bender (Futurama)
44. Zorro
45. Puff the Magic Dragon
46. Gamera

48. Godzilla
49. Bugs Bunny

52. The Raven
53. Samwise Gamgee
54. Optimus Prime
55. Tarzan
56. Snake Plissken
57. Gaius Baltar (BSG)

59. BA Baracus (A-Team)
60. The Equalizer
61. Spider-man
62. Guyver
63. John Crichton (Farscape)
64. Obi-Wan Kenobi

 

[Starman]

1. Batman
2. Cthulhu
3. Jonah Hex
4. The Doctor
5. Jack Bauer
6. Jack Burton
7. Sherlock Holmes
8. Keyser Soze (The Usual Suspects)
9. Adrian Monk
10. Raistlin Majere
11. Javert (Les Miserables)
12. 'Dirty' Harry Callahan
13. Indiana Jones
14. Han Solo
15. The Gray Mouser
16. Batgirl (Barbara Gordon)
17. Hannibal Lecter
18. Rufus (Kim Possible)
19. Samurai Jack
20. Gandalf
21. Dream (The Sandman)
22. Rick Blaine
23. Odysseus
24. Hal Jordan
25. Buffy Summers
26. Andrew "Ender" Wiggin
27. Sepiroth
28. Gregory House (House)
29. Gul Dakat (Star Trek: DS9)
30. The Terminator
31. Det. Vic Mackey
32. Yoda
33. Captain Jack Sparrow
34. T-1000
35. King Kong
36. Jean Luc-Picard
37. R2-D2
38. Dr. Spock
39. Gaston (Beauty & the Beast)
40. The Bride (Kill Bill)
41. Khan
42. Conan
43. Lex Luthor
44. HAL 9000
45. Ra's al Ghul
46. The Joker
47. Captain James T. Kirk
48. Professor Moriarty
49. Bugs Bunny
50. Madmartigan (Willow)
51. Michael Corleone
52. John Locke (Lost)
53. Samwise Gamgee
54. Optimus Prime
55. Eddard Stark (A Game of Thrones)
56. Snake Plissken
57. Gaius Baltar (BSG)
58. Minsc (Baldur's Gate)
59. King Lear
60. The Nameless One (Placescape: Torment)
61. King Arthur
62. Superman
63. Captain Malcolm "Mal" Reynolds
64. Obi-Wan Kenobi

 

[AdamBomb]

some of these matchups are hard, and a few I'm not familiar with either. here's my picks anyway.

1. Angus MacGyver vs. Batman
2. Cthulhu vs. Doomsday (Superman Villain)
3. The Cheshire Cat vs. Jonah Hex
4. Edmund Blackadder vs. The Doctor
5. Wonder Woman vs. Jack Bauer
6. Jack Burton vs. Master Chief
7. Sherlock Holmes vs. Maxwell Smart
8. Robin Hood vs. Keyser Soze (The Usual Suspects)
9. Captain Jeffrey T. Spaulding vs. Adrian Monk
10. Raistlin Majere vs. Alfred Bester
11. Javert (Les Miserables) vs. KITT
12. 'Dirty' Harry Callahan vs. Dr. Anton Phibes
13. Indiana Jones vs. Austin Powers
14. Han Solo vs. Ozymandias (Watchmen)
15. The Wicked Witch of the West vs. The Gray Mouser
16. Batgirl (Barbara Gordon) vs. David Xanatos (Gargoyles)
17. Mario vs. Hannibal Lecter
18. Rufus (Kim Possible) vs. Spongebob Squarepants
19. Harry Potter vs. Samurai Jack
20. Tommy Oliver (Power Rangers) vs. Gandalf
21. Jin vs. Dream (The Sandman)
22. Æon Flux vs. Rick Blaine
23. "Latino Heat" Eddie Guerrero (Pro-Wrestling) vs. Odysseus
24. Gil Grissom vs. Hal Jordan
25. Buffy Summers vs. Rembrandt Brown (Sliders)
26. Gollum vs. Andrew "Ender" Wiggin
27. Tigger vs. Sepiroth
28. Johnny 5 (Short Circuit) vs. Gregory House (House)
29. The Tick vs. Gul Dakat (Star Trek: DS9)
30. James Bond vs. The Terminator
31. Det. Vic Mackey vs. Allan Quartermain
32. Yoda vs. Solomon Kane (Robert E. Howard)
33. Captain Jack Sparrow vs. Darth Vader
34. Belloq vs. T-1000
35. King Kong vs. Rooster Cogburn (True Grit)
36. Odo (Star Trek: DS9) vs. Jean Luc-Picard
37. R2-D2 vs. Booster Gold (DC Comics)
38. Dr. Spock vs. Mugen
39. Horatio Hornblower vs. Gaston (Beauty & the Beast)
40. Doctor Evil vs. The Bride (Kill Bill)
41. Bananaman vs. Khan
42. Conan vs. Honor Harrington
43. Bender (Futurama) vs. Lex Luthor
44. Zorro vs. HAL 9000
45. Ra's al Ghul vs. Puff the Magic Dragon
46. The Joker vs. Gamera
47. Captain Nemo vs. Captain James T. Kirk
48. Professor Moriarty vs. Godzilla
49. Dr. Rodney McKay vs. Bugs Bunny
50. Major Toht vs. Madmartigan (Willow)
51. Michael Corleone vs. Elric of Melniboné
52. The Raven vs. John Locke (Lost)
53. Samwise Gamgee vs. Danger Mouse
54. Optimus Prime vs. Zatoichi
55. Eddard Stark (A Game of Thrones) vs. Tarzan
56. Snake Plissken vs. Dr. Frankenstein
57. The Lone Ranger vs. Gaius Baltar (BSG)
58. Minsc (Baldur's Gate) vs. Inspector Jacques Clouseau
59. BA Baracus (A-Team) vs. King Lear
60. The Nameless One (Placescape: Torment) vs. The Equalizer
61. King Arthur vs. Spider-man
62. Guyver vs. Superman
63. John Crichton (Farscape) vs. Captain Malcolm "Mal" Reynolds
64. Dracula vs. Obi-Wan Kenobi

 

[DM_Matt]

1. Batman
2. Doomsday (Superman Villain)
3.
4.
5. Jack Bauer
6. Master Chief
7. Sherlock Holmes
8. Keyser Soze
9. Adrian Monk
10.
11. KITT
12. 'Dirty' Harry Callahan
13. Indiana Jones
14.
15.
16. Batgirl
17. Hannibal Lecter
18.
19. Samurai Jack
20. Gandalf
21. Jin
22.
23. Odysseus
24. Hal Jordan
25. Buffy Summers
26. Gollum
27.
28. Gregory House
29. The Tick
30. The Terminator
31. Allan Quartermain
32. Yoda
33. Darth Vader
34.
35.
36.
37. R2-D2
38. Dr. Spock
39. Horatio Hornblower
40. The Bride
41.
42.
43. Lex Luthor
44. Zorro
45. Ra's al Ghul
46. The Joker
47.Captain James T. Kirk
48. Professor Moriarty
49. Dr. Rodney McKay
50.
51.
52.
53. Samwise Gamgee
54. Optimus Prime
55.
56. Dr. Frankenstein
57. The Lone Ranger
58.
59.
60.
61. King Arthur
62. Superman
63. Captain Malcolm "Mal" Reynolds
64. Dracula

 

[PhoenixDarkDirk]

1. Angus MacGyver vs. Batman
2. Cthulhu vs. Doomsday (Superman Villain)
3. The Cheshire Cat vs. Jonah Hex
4. Edmund Blackadder vs. The Doctor
5. Wonder Woman vs. Jack Bauer
6. Jack Burton vs. Master Chief
7. Sherlock Holmes vs. Maxwell Smart
8. Robin Hood vs. Keyser Soze (The Usual Suspects)
9. Captain Jeffrey T. Spaulding vs. Adrian Monk
10. Raistlin Majere vs. Alfred Bester
11. Javert (Les Miserables) vs. KITT
12. 'Dirty' Harry Callahan vs. Dr. Anton Phibes
13. Indiana Jones vs. Austin Powers
14. Han Solo vs. Ozymandias (Watchmen)
15. The Wicked Witch of the West vs. The Gray Mouser
16. Batgirl (Barbara Gordon) vs. David Xanatos (Gargoyles)
17. Mario vs. Hannibal Lecter
18. Rufus (Kim Possible) vs. Spongebob Squarepants
19. Harry Potter vs. Samurai Jack
20. Tommy Oliver (Power Rangers) vs. Gandalf
21. Jin vs. Dream (The Sandman)
22. Æon Flux vs. Rick Blaine
23. "Latino Heat" Eddie Guerrero (Pro-Wrestling) vs. Odysseus Guerrero shouldn't even be included because he's real.
24. Gil Grissom vs. Hal Jordan
25. Buffy Summers vs. Rembrandt Brown (Sliders) I won't be surprised if I'm on the losing side of this, considering the competition.
26. Gollum vs. Andrew "Ender" Wiggin
27. Tigger vs. Sepiroth
28. Johnny 5 (Short Circuit) vs. Gregory House (House)
29. The Tick vs. Gul Dakat (Star Trek: DS9)
30. James Bond vs. The Terminator
31. Det. Vic Mackey vs. Allan Quartermain
32. Yoda vs. Solomon Kane (Robert E. Howard)
33. Captain Jack Sparrow vs. Darth Vader
34. Belloq vs. T-1000
35. King Kong vs. Rooster Cogburn (True Grit)
36. Odo (Star Trek: DS9) vs. Jean Luc-Picard
37. R2-D2 vs. Booster Gold (DC Comics)
38. Dr. Spock vs. Mugen
39. Horatio Hornblower vs. Gaston (Beauty & the Beast)
40. Doctor Evil vs. The Bride (Kill Bill)
41. Bananaman vs. Khan
42. Conan vs. Honor Harrington
43. Bender (Futurama) vs. Lex Luthor
44. Zorro vs. HAL 9000
45. Ra's al Ghul vs. Puff the Magic Dragon
46. The Joker vs. Gamera
47. Captain Nemo vs. Captain James T. Kirk
48. Professor Moriarty vs. Godzilla
49. Dr. Rodney McKay vs. Bugs Bunny
50. Major Toht vs. Madmartigan (Willow)
51. Michael Corleone vs. Elric of Melniboné
52. The Raven vs. John Locke (Lost)
53. Samwise Gamgee vs. Danger Mouse
54. Optimus Prime vs. Zatoichi
55. Eddard Stark (A Game of Thrones) vs. Tarzan
56. Snake Plissken vs. Dr. Frankenstein
57. The Lone Ranger vs. Gaius Baltar (BSG)
58. Minsc (Baldur's Gate) vs. Inspector Jacques Clouseau
59. BA Baracus (A-Team) vs. King Lear
60. The Nameless One (Placescape: Torment) vs. The Equalizer
61. King Arthur vs. Spider-man
62. Guyver vs. Superman
63. John Crichton (Farscape) vs. Captain Malcolm "Mal" Reynolds
64. Dracula vs. Obi-Wan Kenobi

 

[Ilium]

1. Angus MacGyver vs. Batman
2. Cthulhu vs. Doomsday (Superman Villain)
3. The Cheshire Cat vs. Jonah Hex
4. Edmund Blackadder vs. The Doctor
5. Wonder Woman vs. Jack Bauer
6. Jack Burton vs. Master Chief
7. Sherlock Holmes vs. Maxwell Smart
8. Robin Hood vs. Keyser Soze (The Usual Suspects)
9. Captain Jeffrey T. Spaulding vs. Adrian Monk
10. Raistlin Majere vs. Alfred Bester
11. Javert (Les Miserables) vs. KITT
12. 'Dirty' Harry Callahan vs. Dr. Anton Phibes
13. Indiana Jones vs. Austin Powers
14. Han Solo vs. Ozymandias (Watchmen)
15. The Wicked Witch of the West vs. The Gray Mouser
16. Batgirl (Barbara Gordon) vs. David Xanatos (Gargoyles)
17. Mario vs. Hannibal Lecter
18. Rufus (Kim Possible) vs. Spongebob Squarepants
19. Harry Potter vs. Samurai Jack
20. Tommy Oliver (Power Rangers) vs. Gandalf
21. Jin vs. Dream (The Sandman)
22. Æon Flux vs. Rick Blaine
23. "Latino Heat" Eddie Guerrero (Pro-Wrestling) vs. Odysseus
24. Gil Grissom vs. Hal Jordan
25. Buffy Summers vs. Rembrandt Brown (Sliders)
26. Gollum vs. Andrew "Ender" Wiggin
27. Tigger vs. Sepiroth
28. Johnny 5 (Short Circuit) vs. Gregory House (House)
29. The Tick vs. Gul Dakat (Star Trek: DS9)
30. James Bond vs. The Terminator
31. Det. Vic Mackey vs. Allan Quartermain
32. Yoda vs. Solomon Kane (Robert E. Howard)
33. Captain Jack Sparrow vs. Darth Vader
34. Belloq vs. T-1000
35. King Kong vs. Rooster Cogburn (True Grit)
36. Odo (Star Trek: DS9) vs. Jean Luc-Picard
37. R2-D2 vs. Booster Gold (DC Comics)
38. Dr. Spock vs. Mugen
39. Horatio Hornblower vs. Gaston (Beauty & the Beast)
40. Doctor Evil vs. The Bride (Kill Bill)
41. Bananaman vs. Khan
42. Conan vs. Honor Harrington
43. Bender (Futurama) vs. Lex Luthor
44. Zorro vs. HAL 9000
45. Ra's al Ghul vs. Puff the Magic Dragon
46. The Joker vs. Gamera
47. Captain Nemo vs. Captain James T. Kirk
48. Professor Moriarty vs. Godzilla
49. Dr. Rodney McKay vs. Bugs Bunny
50. Major Toht vs. Madmartigan (Willow)
51. Michael Corleone vs. Elric of Melniboné
52. The Raven vs. John Locke (Lost)
53. Samwise Gamgee vs. Danger Mouse
54. Optimus Prime vs. Zatoichi
55. Eddard Stark (A Game of Thrones) vs. Tarzan
56. Snake Plissken vs. Dr. Frankenstein
57. The Lone Ranger vs. Gaius Baltar (BSG)
58. Minsc (Baldur's Gate) vs. Inspector Jacques Clouseau
59. BA Baracus (A-Team) vs. King Lear
60. The Nameless One (Placescape: Torment) vs. The Equalizer
61. King Arthur vs. Spider-man
62. Guyver vs. Superman
63. John Crichton (Farscape) vs. Captain Malcolm "Mal" Reynolds
64. Dracula vs. Obi-Wan Kenobi