Gorgon Zee
Hero
I went to UKGE and saw no Americans; my conclusion is that Americans don’t play D&D
...
How many 20 yr old new gamers have even heard of Origins, let alone travelled there?
Your comparison (even with the smiley) is silly. I wasn't just looking at one group and saying "D&D players are old". I was comparing two groups drawn form the same population. The correct analog would be to say "I went to UKGE and saw no Americans playing D&D, but many of them playing Indie Games; my conclusion is that Americans don’t play D&D" which would, honestly, be a reasonable conclusion.
The second point suffers the same issue -- even if the Origins crowd skews older, why do those who play D&D skew older than the Indie game crowd?
You could posit that there is some interaction between the three factors -- perhaps that young d&d players stay away from Origins, or that young indie game players really like origins. That doesn't seem likely to me, but maybe.
I am curious though, does anyone have some demographic info on GenCon or Origins attendees?