I chose option #1. For me, geeky activities come in categories. Am I...
...willing to talk about it at work?
I'm open about most of my leisure writing hobbies, like my blog and my posts at Sneakery.
I'm willing to admit that I play videogames at work, but I won't bring up the subject on my own. (I'd likely be more willing if most of my coworkers weren't middle-aged women.)
...willing to talk about it with casual friends?
Both of the above are perfectly appropriate fodder for cocktail parties, and I'll combine the two by mentioning that I sometimes write video game reviews.
In a more casual setting like this, I'll also mention that I read comic books.
This is also the category that covers what I'd "reveal" to a girl I'm casually dating
...willing to talk about it with my best friends?
Only the people closest to me know I play RPGs, and some of them make lighthearted fun of me for it.
My big ol' collection of Star Wars action figures also falls under this category.
If I took up CCGs or miniature games again, they'd also be here.
I'm a pretty confident guy, but the people I hang out with don't "get" roleplaying, and those that do consider it the nerdiest of the nerdy hobbies. I'm not really comfortable seeking out new friends to game with, partly because when I do, they're people who seem a bit weird to me. (I know that sounds ironic, but I've never physically met gamers who didn't fall at least partly into the greasy-haired, socially awkward, Weird Al-listening stereotype who weren't already my friends.)
...willing to talk about it at work?
I'm open about most of my leisure writing hobbies, like my blog and my posts at Sneakery.
I'm willing to admit that I play videogames at work, but I won't bring up the subject on my own. (I'd likely be more willing if most of my coworkers weren't middle-aged women.)
...willing to talk about it with casual friends?
Both of the above are perfectly appropriate fodder for cocktail parties, and I'll combine the two by mentioning that I sometimes write video game reviews.
In a more casual setting like this, I'll also mention that I read comic books.
This is also the category that covers what I'd "reveal" to a girl I'm casually dating
...willing to talk about it with my best friends?
Only the people closest to me know I play RPGs, and some of them make lighthearted fun of me for it.
My big ol' collection of Star Wars action figures also falls under this category.
If I took up CCGs or miniature games again, they'd also be here.
I'm a pretty confident guy, but the people I hang out with don't "get" roleplaying, and those that do consider it the nerdiest of the nerdy hobbies. I'm not really comfortable seeking out new friends to game with, partly because when I do, they're people who seem a bit weird to me. (I know that sounds ironic, but I've never physically met gamers who didn't fall at least partly into the greasy-haired, socially awkward, Weird Al-listening stereotype who weren't already my friends.)