D&D 5E (2014) I miss easily scaleable modifiable monsters!

[Eric V]

Sure, but what if I wanted a couple of elites or a better solo-type version of an existing one?

 

[DaveDash]

A week ago I would have talked about how easy it was with the chart of hp and damage.
Now I'm looking at converting Gardmore Abbey to 5e, and the beholder is the wrong level and almost no monsters are perfect, and I kinda miss being able to just add +/-1 to their defences and tweaking damage.

Especially since the MM doesn't line up with the expected numbers in the DMG in the slightest...

A quick formula for changing hp and damage would be nice. I'm sure someone could figure it out.

This. People who says it's easy haven't had 40 pages of NPCs or monsters with class levels (usually spellcasters) to convert, or don't care about building encounters designed to be "just right".

Also converting low level stuff? Not so bad. Mid to high levels? Completely different.

5e has a huge chunk of monsters around CR4-5. Older editions have a more linear spread. So when you start converting higher level stuff you end up with a lot more work on your hands.

 

[Rhenny]

In nearly every hard or deadly encounter I designate 1 of the bad guys to be the squad leader/captain. I'll buff his hit points and give him a feat or special ability. I really like using even just 2 or 3 levels in a class also.

Having the monsters work differently than PCs is awesome. For monsters, there is no wrong way to make a foe. It is liberating and encourages creativity.

I think the key is to understand some of the bigger ways that creature abilities affect CR. Giving a monster spellcasting ability (especially area attacks or crowd control spells), breathe weapons/area attacks, petrification, death gazes, etc., make an encounter more difficult. Other than that, a lightly modified monster in a group -- one with 25% more hit points, maybe slightly better armor and a feat-like ability, only changes the encounter a little bit...mostly to make it more surprising for the players, not so much more difficult.

Since I run nearly all my games online using Fantasy Grounds, I even let the tabletop generate random hit points for most of the foes so that the players never truly know how easy or hard it will be to hurt even the lone bugbear.

 

[Jester David]

Looking at the DMG, from levels 1 to 20:

+/- 15 hit points per CR difference
+/- 6 damage per CR difference
+/- 1 attack/safe DC for every 4 CR difference