IF a PDFs of the 3 core books were leaked, would you:

What would you do

  • Ignore it and avoid reading spoilers.

    Votes: 30 4.5%
  • Check out spoilers, but not download them

    Votes: 52 7.9%
  • Download them and start playing, still buy official version

    Votes: 552 83.5%
  • Download, play, cancel pre-orders.

    Votes: 27 4.1%

I would most likely download , and no matter what I am still buying. Only reason I would download is to kick off the game earlier. Not having anything to run since I know that 4th ed will usurp it is making a stale game environment for my group.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

RandomCitizenX said:
I would most likely download , and no matter what I am still buying. Only reason I would download is to kick off the game earlier. Not having anything to run since I know that 4th ed will usurp it is making a stale game environment for my group.

complete agreement
 

phil500 said:
4E - IF a PDFs of the 3 core books were leaked, would you:

...you mean, like this one?

http://www.enworld.org/showthread.php?t=221806

I don't consider a game important enough to be tempted at doing something that can cause me legal problems. But you can't really prevent information to spread around early or late... as soon as 4e books are on the shelves, we'll have dozens of forums and websites broadcasting spoilers and snippets everywhere. If I found those spoilers on EnWorld two months earlier than expected, yes I'd click that link and read. If I'd have to do something more complicated or risky than that, I simply won't.
 
Last edited:


arscott said:
rescuing puppies from a burning building and then eating them does not make you neutral.
I don't see the parallel here. Perhaps it would be more like eating the puppies, regurgitating them, and then raising them? The harm(eating the puppies), I would assume, would be that WotC would lose $ because you are downloading the rules without buying them. However, if you buy the books anyway, you may still be breaking the law, but you're hardly eating puppies. I could be wrong though. Emotional damage? That's hard to fix. I really don't like it when I don't get it. :confused: :D
 

The answers on this poll were very strange, i would probably go for something like "download, read rules, learn system, NOT play."

I wouldn't have any qualms about downloading the books to start learning the rules and prepping my game. I probably wouldn't read it cover from cover though(scanned pdf's doesn't really make for good electronic reading imo), so i guess it would be a quick-skim sort of thing where you start checking out how the core gameplay will work, what the classes looks like etc etc(if it was out today things might be different, that would be very early. then again the forums would be filled with information within hours and there would be no point in not getting it, so devil and the deep-blue-sea there).

But I would not try to play the game without the books in my hands, its just too much back and forth between the pc and the game-table. Neither would i print it out, it would be a waste of paper and just a big mess. i might be impatient, but there are always something to kill the time with.

Pen and paper roleplaying games isn't the sort of business that i expect have a big problem with piracy. I would have to say you would be at an epic moral low if you start printing out these books instead of buying them (i would have guessed the printing alone would cost just as much as the original books :lol: )



Anyway, first post here wohoo. I know its a bad first impression when i waste it on halfway defending piracy... But i find this a pretty clear-cut case of non-problematic 'spoilerhunting'/knowledge-expanding, which i don't think would hurt their economy. PR and marketing-wise though, it might be a disturbing thing, so nothing's black and white...
 

arscott said:
rescuing puppies from a burning building and then eating them does not make you neutral.

I don't know, if the puppies knew the complete 4E rules and you could gain their knowledge by eating them?

Fire up the grill.
 


RandomCitizenX said:
I would most likely download , and no matter what I am still buying. Only reason I would download is to kick off the game earlier. Not having anything to run since I know that 4th ed will usurp it is making a stale game environment for my group.

Yeah this is hurting my gaming group, so far we have done Boardgame nights and 1 shot nights( of any of the games I bought out of impulse-Next week its cthulhutech night) and the on and off Shadowrun games. We dont decide on a game since in 2 months we will shut down everything and inmerse into 4e. :(
 


Remove ads

Top