D&D 5E If you don't like ASI at character creation...

[Guest 7037866]

AD&D 1st edition Method III is the best rolling method.

LOL you averaged over 14 for each score. Granted you needed that to have any hope of a bonus to things, but still...

 

[Corinnguard]

LOL you averaged over 14 for each score. Granted you needed that to have any hope of a bonus to things, but still...

Or you need to roll on a prayer.

 

[TwoSix]

LOL you averaged over 14 for each score. Granted you needed that to have any hope of a bonus to things, but still...

You say that like it isn’t a good thing.

 

[Guest 7037866]

You say that like it isn’t a good thing.

Given the distribution it creates, I'd just roll d6+d4+8. It has a slightly lower average, but over all would be quite a bit less dice rolling (if you think that isn't a good thing, too, I guess...).

 

[TwoSix]

Given the distribution it creates, I'd just roll d6+d4+8. It has a slightly lower average, but over all would be quite a bit less dice rolling (if you think that isn't a good thing, too, I guess...).

Makes it a little too controlled for my tastes. If you’re going to roll, you might as well roll 36 times and make it a real event.

 

[Horwath]

Given the distribution it creates, I'd just roll d6+d4+8. It has a slightly lower average, but over all would be quite a bit less dice rolling (if you think that isn't a good thing, too, I guess...).

or pointbuy roll:

2d8+2 is worth 0
2d6+6 is worth 1pt
2d4+10 is worth 2pts

you have 7 pts.

 

[Guest 7037866]

or pointbuy roll:

2d8+2 is worth 0
2d6+6 is worth 1pt
2d4+10 is worth 2pts

you have 7 pts.

Point-buy again...?

0 => 4 - 18, avg. 11
1 => 8 - 18, avg. 13
2 => 12 - 18, avg. 15

Not my cup of tea, personally, ... and has nothing mentioned about replacing ASI...