Iron Bands of Bilarro and Coup de Grace?

Arravis

First Post
If a creature is held immobile in Iron Bands of Bilarro (Iron Bands of Bindingin SRD), can another creature perform a coup de grace on the victim? Thanks for any info guys!
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I would say yes, as the Iron Bands, literally wrap the character up in them. Its not a cage where they can dodge the strike. The best you could do is roll around, and that could be easily handled by the person making a coup de grace.
 

Just seems that they would have mentioned "helpless" in the wording of the item. A grapple pin might actually seem more appropriate.
 

The target is "held immobile."

I'd imagine that this works similar to paralysis which does render someone helpless.

Alternatively, you could rule it as an entaglement effect, meaning they cannot move, and are treated as having a Dex penalty.
 

If the target is capable in any way of responding to your attack, even such a simple motion as turning their head or rolling would be enough to not be "helpless" per the rules. Helpless is a very specific condition and very few situations grant it.
 

Arravis said:
If a creature is held immobile in Iron Bands of Bilarro (Iron Bands of Bindingin SRD), can another creature perform a coup de grace on the victim?
After looking up the definition of "helpless", I was going to say 'yes, of course'. But then I noticed the definition of "pinned": Held immobile (but not helpless) in a grapple.

I'm still going to go with "yes", because you break free from the bands much the same way as if you were bound (=helpless), and not with a grapple check.
 

To play devil's advocate:

"A helpless character is paralyzed, held, bound, sleeping, unconscious, or otherwise completely at an opponent’s mercy."

The bands would be pretty... binding. It would seem to fit.
 

Iku, I think the pinned solution might be the most practical. While not explicitly, or even implicitly, stated, it does seem to fit. I just cannot imagine they meant helpless without stating it outright.
 

Arravis said:
Iku, I think the pinned solution might be the most practical. While not explicitly, or even implicitly, stated, it does seem to fit. I just cannot imagine they meant helpless without stating it outright.
But you have no problem imagining that they meant "pinned" without stating it outright? :confused:
 


Remove ads

Top