Is the Warforged hosed vs. the Warforged Domain?

[pawsplay]

I don't think it's any more bizarre than the Plant domain, which lets you turn/rebuke undead. There's precedent for this mechanic in a number or places.

Personally, I think that the only problem with this domain is that it just isn't very fun for the victim, and the victim is pretty likely to be a PC. As a player, it's generally more fun to roll the dice and have you character fail than to watch the DM throw the dice and have their character win.

I think it would be fine if used in moderation. Could make an interesting BBEG.

Plants, at least, seem like a natural force. Warforged seem like the end result of a very specific set of enchantments and rituals.

 

[pawsplay]

I would rather be effected by the various "person" spells than be immune.

So many times while I have been either playing in a group with a warforged or playing a warforged myself I have wanted to be able to be effected by enlarge or reduce person. One time it would have prevented a total-party-kill.

That's why God invented psionics.