Ahglock said:Yeah I've heard this argument, and it just doesn't work for me. For those who this does work, hey great maybe the 4e per encounter system will be a lot of fun for you. I'll be wincing on the inside every time I use it if I switch.
I'm not saying it's a better system though. I did note its pitfalls - namely it's very abstract and takes away the skill of the setup.
In short, I also share your pain. I'm just saying it in a pretty neutral fashion.