• NOW LIVE! Into the Woods--new character species, eerie monsters, and haunting villains to populate the woodlands of your D&D games.

Joss Whedon on X-Men?

I hope this rumor is true as well.

Personally, I've found Morrison's run to be extremely unpleasant. I dropped it from my month batch of comics quite a few months ago.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I find Morrisson to be an over-rated and derivitive comic writer who ran through mosto f his good ideas with Doom Patrol and the first series of Invisibles.

I dropped his X-men from my monthly buying about a year ago, but Joss Whedon - now him I'd be excited about.
 
Last edited:

nemmerle said:
I find Morrisson to be an over-rated and derivitive comic writer who ran through mosto f his good ideas with Doom Patrol and the first series of Invisibles.
Grrrrrrr....

Could it be that Morrison had such a bloody brilliant run in his earlier works [Animal Man/Doom Patrol/Invisibles] that he's reaching the point of creative fatigue that most artists unfortunately arrive to? I don't much care for his later work either, but that shouldn't diminish his earlier achievement.

And who is he derivitive of? I'll give you Alan Moore [though I think its far more fair to say that they're writers in the same vein, with the same unlikey knack for turning their personal intellectual obsessions into compelling stories]. Who else? Jorge Luis Borges? 20th Century Art?

I don't always like what Morrison does, not even back in the day. But he's a master synthesist [which isn't quite the same as being derivative]. I can't overstate how much credit I give him for combining his love of comics, literature, lit. theory, superheroes, avant-garde science, metafictional gamesmanship, pop cultural observation, and various strains of philoshophy/mysticism into readable works. That fact that he had any success at all, in terms of the works themselves or proffessionally, is clear sign he more than just an overrated hack.

Not that that means you should like his stuff :)

[edit] Oh yeah, and Joss Whedon+X-Men=yay!
 
Last edited:

Funny, I was thinking of Borges. In fact, he straight ripped off Borges in a Doom Patrol story without so much as giving an ounce of credit.

Even some of his JLA stories seem derivative of his own earlier work with Doom Patrol.

And I though Animal Man was over-rated as well - esp. the horrible wholly unoriginal "meeting the author" ending. :rolleyes:

-- Doesn't Like Frank Miller Either Nemm :D
 

nemmerle said:
Funny, I was thinking of Borges. In fact, he straight ripped off Borges in a Doom Patrol story without so much as giving an ounce of credit.
You know, I always thought it was great that Morrison's first Doom Patrol arc was essentially the superhero version of Borges's "Tlon, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius" . But come to rethink it, you could call it plagiarism as easily as inspiration. Crediting JLB would have been the right thing to do...
 
Last edited:

Maybe I'll start reading New X-Men again. When Magneto walked into New York and took it over without so much as a mention of the Avengers, FF, Punisher, Spider-Man [edit] or DOCTOR STRANGE, for crying out loud [/edit], etc, I threw the comic in the fire and quit reading.
 
Last edited:

Mallus said:
Crediting JLB would have been the right thing to do...
You're right, of course.

But hey, call me easily satisfied, but the fact that a comic book writer has read "Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius" is more than enough to make me happy. At least, Morrison didn't steal a lousy story. :)
 
Last edited:


Klaus said:
New X-Men are (IIRC): Wolverine (Logan/James Howlett)

What the heck?! What happened to Hugh Jackman? He is Logan in the first two movies. Please say it isn't so. If this is true why should I bother to see X3? Wolverine is the reason why I love X-Men, and if the same actor can not be in all three movies, then what the heck were the directors thinking? This just makes me steam!
 

Golem2176 said:
What the heck?! What happened to Hugh Jackman? He is Logan in the first two movies. Please say it isn't so. If this is true why should I bother to see X3? Wolverine is the reason why I love X-Men, and if the same actor can not be in all three movies, then what the heck were the directors thinking? This just makes me steam!
James Howlett is Logan "full name" in the comics, not the actor who has/is playing him. No relation.
 

Into the Woods

Remove ads

Top